Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
What is the most common serious conviction leading to deportation from the US in 2025?
Executive summary
Available sources do not provide a single, definitive “most common serious conviction” that led to deportations in 2025; reporting and agency data point instead to a mix of non‑criminal immigration violations, traffic and minor offenses (including DUI and drug possession), and a smaller share of violent crimes — for example, Migration Policy and ICE materials note DUI, drug possession and assault among commonly arrested convictions [1] [2], while New York Times found roughly 8% of arrests had a violent‑crime conviction and about 9% had a traffic conviction [3].
1. No clear single “most common serious conviction” in available reporting
The provided materials do not identify one specific serious criminal conviction that most often triggered deportation in 2025. Migration Policy’s review of available FY2025 data and ICE’s public statistics describe categories and common convictions (DUI, drug possession, assault, non‑civil traffic offenses) among people ERO historically arrests [1] [2]. Those summaries emphasize patterns rather than naming one dominant serious crime [1] [2].
2. Large share of deportees had no criminal conviction — immigration status often decisive
Multiple analyses report that a majority of people in ICE custody or targeted in 2025 enforcement did not have a criminal conviction. Migration Policy found that ICE conducted many removals of noncitizens with orders or voluntary departures in FY2025 [2], and MPI noted 71% of ICE detainees had no criminal conviction as of September 2025 [4]. ICE’s own public materials list large categories of removals that are immigration violations rather than criminal convictions (visa overstays, re‑entry after deportation, fugitives) [1].
3. When convictions are present they are often non‑violent or traffic‑related
ICE’s published arrest history says ERO most commonly arrests immigration violators with convictions such as DUI, drug possession, assault and criminal traffic offenses like hit‑and‑run [1]. New York Times analysis of recent arrests reported roughly 9% had a traffic conviction and roughly 8% a violent‑crime conviction, indicating traffic and minor crimes are more common than violent felonies among those arrested [3].
4. Government messaging vs. independent data: competing narratives
Department of Homeland Security statements emphasize criminality in enforcement: a DHS release claimed “70% of ICE arrests are of criminal illegal aliens charged with or convicted of a crime” and touted large removal numbers [5]. Independent analyses and FOIA‑based reporting pushed back: TRAC and Newsweek cite internal data showing many targeted people lack criminal convictions and that DHS definitions can blur immigration violations and criminal offenses [6] [7]. This is a clear disagreement between official framing and outside analysts [5] [7].
5. Why “serious conviction” is a fuzzy category in practice
Sources show several reasons a single answer is elusive: (a) DHS and ICE sometimes classify immigration violations as “crimes” for public messaging [6]; (b) prosecution and removal timelines differ — people with convictions may be detained longer before removal, skewing snapshots [2]; and (c) mass interior enforcement in 2025 swept many with no criminal records, shifting the composition of those deported [4] [8].
6. What the numbers tell us about violent crime convictions
Reporting that directly quantifies violent‑crime convictions among those arrested is limited but consistent: the New York Times analysis found roughly 8% of those arrested had been convicted of a violent crime [3]. That proportion is substantially smaller than the shares with no conviction or with minor/traffic offenses in the public analyses [3] [4].
7. Bottom line and how to read future claims
Based on the available sources, the most common convictions associated with ICE arrests and removals in 2025 were DUI, drug possession, assault and criminal traffic offenses — while a majority of detainees had no criminal conviction at all and violent‑crime convictions made up a relatively small share [1] [4] [3]. Official DHS claims that most arrests are of “criminal illegal aliens” conflict with FOIA‑based and independent reporting that many are immigration violators without convictions [5] [7]. For a definitive single “most common serious conviction,” further agency breakdowns distinguishing “serious” from “minor” crimes would be required — available sources do not provide that specific consolidated ranking [1] [2].
Limitations: public DHS/ICE detailed conviction‑level tables for 2025 are incomplete in the sources provided, and independent analyses use different methods and timeframes, which accounts for some of the differences in interpretation [2] [7].