Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
How does New York City's crime rate compare to the national average in 2025?
Executive summary
New York City’s official reports show notable declines in many major crime categories through 2025 — the NYPD reported historic lows in shootings and murders for early 2025 and multi-month declines with specific month-to-month drops like a 4.9% fall in May and a 16.8% decline in January versus the prior year [1] [2] [3]. Nationally, multiple independent trackers and research groups report a broad drop in violent crime in the first half of 2025 — for example, the Council on Criminal Justice (CCJ) and related analyses document falling homicides, gun assaults and other offenses across many U.S. cities [4] [5].
1. NYC says it’s down — the police department’s view
The NYPD’s public releases for 2025 emphasize steep reductions: the department announced “record low” shootings and murders for the first five months of 2025 and framed month-to-month improvements (e.g., a 4.9% drop in May and a 16.8% decline in January 2025 compared with the prior year) while noting seizure of thousands of illegal guns as part of its enforcement strategy [1] [2] [6].
2. Independent analyses show mixed but broadly falling trends
Non-government analyses and think tanks largely corroborate declines across many cities and nationally in 2025: the Council on Criminal Justice documents declines in aggravated assault, gun assaults, robbery and other offenses in mid‑2025, and multiple analysts show homicide declines in many sampled cities [4] [5]. The Manhattan Institute highlighted large quarter-to-quarter drops in NYC’s murders (34%) and shootings (23%) in early 2025, noting the gains may be fragile [7].
3. How NYC compares to the national picture — similar direction, different details
Both NYC reporting and national studies show crime falling in 2025, but the scale and timing differ. NYC’s press releases and CompStat products report citywide index declines and historic lows in specific categories [6] [3] [2] [8]. At the same time, CCJ and other national trackers document broad declines across many—but not all—cities and warn that national reductions are driven in part by large changes in a subset of high‑rate cities [4] [5]. In short: NYC’s direction mirrors the national trend of falling crime in 2025, but city-level magnitudes and which offenses move most vary from national aggregates [8] [4].
4. Apples-to-oranges risks: measurement, reporting and definitions
Comparisons between NYC and national averages are constrained by reporting differences. The NYPD’s CompStat and citywide reports follow New York State Penal Law categories and local methods that “differ from the crime categories used by the FBI Uniform Crime Reporting Program,” and not all jurisdictions report the same way or timeliness to national trackers [9] [8]. CCJ and RTCI samples use a subset of cities and agencies, which can bias national trends if a few large cities drive the change [4] [10]. Analysts caution that shifts in reporting, legal definitions, and which agencies submit timely data can affect apparent rates [9] [4].
5. Where NYC diverges from peers and why that matters
Some analysts point out that NYC has “defied” broader patterns at times — Bloomberg noted NYC remained more elevated than pre‑pandemic levels despite recent drops, and Vital City projected that NY would show smaller decreases in murders compared with many peer cities through 2025 [11] [12]. That matters because national averages can mask important local variation: a city can see strong gains in property crime declines while lagging in specific violent‑crime reductions or vice versa [12] [5].
6. Competing narratives and political framing
City officials highlight enforcement successes (gun seizures, special deployments) when promoting NYC’s declines, while independent outlets and analysts both confirm declines and warn against overclaiming causation or long‑term stability — for example, Politico challenged some mayoral assertions even as it acknowledged low murder rates in some periods [1] [13] [6]. National commentators and policymakers likewise disagree on whether the 2025 drop validates particular policies; some urge caution about attributing causality because declines began earlier and vary by location [14] [5].
7. Bottom line and reporting limitations
Available sources show NYC experienced substantial declines in many major crimes in 2025 and the national trend for early‑to‑mid 2025 was also downward, but direct statements that NYC’s overall crime rate is uniformly better or worse than the national average require careful, standardized per‑capita comparison using harmonized definitions — which is complicated by differing reporting systems and the fact that national declines are partly driven by a subset of cities [1] [8] [4]. For precise numeric comparisons (e.g., crimes per 100,000 in 2025), consult the NYPD’s published citywide crime statistics and CCJ/RTCI national datasets and bear in mind the measurement caveats cited above [8] [4].