What is the timeline for multi-level appeals and possible Supreme Court review in federal criminal cases?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
Federal criminal appeals begin almost immediately after a final judgment and proceed on a compressed docket: defendants generally must file a notice of appeal within 14 days, the circuit court’s work typically produces a decision in roughly a year (but can range from a few months to two years), and only a tiny fraction of cases advance to Supreme Court review, which the high court accepts in very few matters each term (about 100–150) [1] [2] [3] [4] [5].
1. Filing the appeal: the hard deadline that starts the clock
The procedural stopwatch in a federal criminal case starts with the defendant’s notice of appeal, which under Rule 4(b) must be filed within 14 days after the later of the judgment or the order disposing of the last timely post‑trial motion; filing deadlines are strict and missing them usually forfeits appellate rights [1] [2] [6]. Post‑trial motions—motions for acquittal, for a new trial under Rule 33, or a motion to correct sentence under Rule 35—can extend when the 14‑day clock runs, because the notice of appeal must be filed within 14 days after the entry of the order disposing of the last such motion [7] [1] [8]. Practical guides and law firms stress that these short windows and interplay between rules make early appellate counsel imperative; that advice reflects both legal reality and the business interests of appellate practitioners [7] [9].
2. Circuit court work: briefs, panels, and the variable calendar
Once the notice is filed, the appeal proceeds to the relevant U.S. Court of Appeals where the case is typically decided on briefs and sometimes oral argument before a three‑judge panel; the process is methodical and governed by each circuit’s briefing and calendaring practices [10] [5]. Practitioners and defender offices report typical appellate dockets resolve in about a year, though timelines are elastic—ranging from a few months for straightforward questions to two years or more for complex or congested dockets [3] [4] [11]. The volume of filings, complexity of issues, and whether the court schedules oral argument or an en banc rehearing all materially affect when a written decision issues [4] [5].
3. Losing in the circuit: rehearing en banc and procedural pauses
A panel decision can be followed by a petition for rehearing by the same panel or an en banc rehearing by the full circuit; those procedures add weeks to months and are granted only in narrow circumstances, particularly where the case involves questions of exceptional importance or circuit precedent [5]. The government’s role differs: it generally may not appeal an acquittal, but can challenge certain interlocutory matters or sentences in limited ways, and the Justice Manual and federal rules contain special timing rules for government filings that can affect overall sequencing [12] [5]. Because rehearing petitions are discretionary, they often reflect strategic calculations by litigants and sometimes institutional priorities — courts manage scarce calendar space and litigants weigh prospects before asking for further review [5].
4. Seeking the Supreme Court: discretionary gatekeeping and low odds
If the circuit appeal ends unfavorably, a party may file a petition for a writ of certiorari asking the Supreme Court to review; the federal defenders’ explanation and court guidance make clear the Supreme Court accepts very few criminal cases—roughly 100–150 grants per term—so certiorari is an exceptional remedy reserved for substantial or circuit‑split questions [3] [5]. Sources provided discuss the petition process and the rarity of grants but do not supply the Supreme Court’s exact filing deadlines or all procedural details for certiorari in criminal cases; that gap should be noted for readers seeking precise timing [3] [5].
5. From start to finish: a practical timeline and caveats
Summing the documented steps: the initial critical deadline is 14 days for the notice of appeal (subject to post‑trial motions) [1] [2]; the appellate decision typically follows in about a year but can be shorter or much longer depending on complexity and court load [3] [4]; rehearing and en banc petitions add more months and are rarely granted [5]; Supreme Court review is discretionary and granted in very few cases each year [3] [5]. Many publicly available guides and law‑firm pages emphasize similar timeframes while also reflecting the commercial incentive to recruit clients for long, technical processes, so users should weigh institutional messaging against neutral court statistics and any case‑specific nuances not covered in the sources cited [7] [4].