How many deportations occurred under the Trump administration compared to other administrations?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
Available sources report widely different counts and definitions for removals under President Trump’s second term: DHS statements claim as many as “more than 605,000” deportations and “more than 2.5 million” people leaving the U.S. when including voluntary departures [1], while independent reporting and analysts put the figure for formal removals during 2025 in the several-hundred-thousand range—roughly 400,000 to 600,000 depending on which agency numbers or DHS claims you accept [2] [3] [4]. Researchers and news outlets warn that DHS stopped publishing the detailed, historically comparable statistics, making cross‑administration comparisons difficult [2] [5].
1. Trump’s tallies vs. independent counts: a gap that matters
DHS press releases under the Trump administration have touted headline totals—e.g., “more than 605,000” deportations and “more than 2.5 million illegal aliens leaving the U.S.” when voluntary self‑deportations and agency‑assisted departures are added—which the department frames as evidence of a record enforcement effort [1]. Independent outlets and analysts, however, report lower and more cautious figures: Reuters cited DHS saying “more than 593,000 people” had been deported by early December but also noted the administration was “likely to fall short” of its 1‑million‑per‑year goal [3]; Axios and The Atlantic describe DHS claims of ~400,000–400,000‑plus removals and flag methodological concerns [2] [4]. The divergence stems from what counts as a “deportation” and reliance on different data streams [2].
2. Definitions and counting choices change the headline
Analysts stress that DHS mixes several categories—formal removals (“deportations”), voluntary departures, and “self‑deportations” incentivized via programs—into public tallies, creating big differences versus historical ICE/DHS reporting conventions [2] [1]. Past administrations published standardized removal statistics; reporting shows DHS under the current administration has curtailed those regular releases, which complicates apples‑to‑apples comparisons with prior presidencies [2] [6]. Brookings and TRAC note that removals historically include both border turns and interior removals, and shifting enforcement and border volumes change totals even when policies tighten [7] [8].
3. How Trump’s pace compares to earlier administrations, by available evidence
Multiple sources say the early months of the Trump term saw a surge in ICE arrests and detention even as overall removals remained in the “hundreds of thousands” rather than in the millions. Reuters and Time report that arrests under Trump have more than doubled compared with recent years, but deportation totals have, until recently, been similar to or below Biden‑era levels in per‑day or per‑period comparisons; Brookings and TRAC find daily removals under Trump often below Biden’s averages during overlapping periods [5] [6] [8] [7]. Migration Policy Institute’s FY2025 review documents increased enforcement and higher detention counts but frames total removals within the same mid‑hundreds‑of‑thousands scale for the year [9].
4. The role of detention, voluntary departures and incentives
Reporting shows the administration rapidly expanded detention capacity and used incentives and an app to encourage so‑called self‑deportations—payments and government‑purchased flights—which are counted by DHS toward its “left the U.S.” totals but are distinct from court‑ordered removals [1] [4] [10]. Migration Policy and Axios analysts note higher detention can prompt people to abandon cases or accept voluntary departure, which inflates DHS’s “left the country” numbers relative to formal deportations recorded in historical ICE datasets [10] [2].
5. What we can and cannot conclude from current reporting
Available sources agree enforcement has intensified and that the administration set an aggressive 1‑million‑per‑year target; they disagree on whether that target is being met and on the correct way to count removals [3] [1] [2]. Sources warn DHS’s reduced public data releases and changes in counting make direct, reliable comparisons with previous administrations difficult or impossible without access to standardized datasets [2] [7]. TRAC and Brookings both recommend treating administration claims cautiously and relying on independent compilation for historical comparisons [8] [7].
6. Bottom line for readers
If you use DHS press releases, the Trump administration’s enforcement totals look record‑breaking—hundreds of thousands of formal removals plus millions “leaving” when voluntary programs are included [1]. Independent reporting and analyst groups place formal removals for 2025 in a lower but still historically large range (roughly 400,000–600,000 depending on source and cut‑offs) and caution that changes in counting, detention strategy, and DHS transparency make direct cross‑administration tallies unreliable without standardized, publicly available data [2] [3] [5] [7]. Available sources do not provide a single, definitive comparable number across administrations [2].