Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Can undocumented immigrants legally obtain a Social Security card in the United States?
Executive Summary
Undocumented immigrants generally cannot legally obtain a Social Security card or Social Security number (SSN) for work because the Social Security Administration (SSA) issues SSNs only to U.S. citizens and noncitizens who are authorized to work by the Department of Homeland Security; exceptions are narrow and limited to specific, documented nonwork federal or state legal requirements [1]. Undocumented residents can, however, obtain an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN) for tax-filing purposes, which does not confer work authorization, immigration status, or automatic entitlement to Social Security benefits [2] [3]. Multiple SSA guidance and recent reporting reiterate this division between SSN eligibility tied to work authorization and ITINs for tax compliance [4] [5].
1. Why SSNs are tied to work authorization — the legal mechanics that matter
The Social Security Administration bases SSN issuance for noncitizens on immigration status documents showing lawful admission or specific work authorization; acceptable evidence includes Lawful Permanent Resident Cards, Employment Authorization Documents, or admission stamps that explicitly permit employment. This linkage is rooted in federal statutes and SSA policy designed to ensure that Social Security benefits and records track contributions from legally authorized workers, so benefits are paid only to those who meet eligibility and contribution requirements [1]. SSA materials and explanatory reporting underscore that applicants without work permission generally cannot get an SSN unless a federal or state statute or regulation requires an SSN for a legitimate nonwork purpose, and in such exceptional cases the applicant must provide agency documentation explaining the legal need [1]. This framework preserves the legal distinction between tax identification and authorization to work.
2. The ITIN alternative: tax compliance without legal status or benefits
For those who cannot obtain an SSN, the IRS issues Individual Taxpayer Identification Numbers (ITINs) for federal tax purposes; ITINs allow filing of tax returns but do not authorize employment or confer immigration status. Advocates and legal guides emphasize that undocumented workers and other nonresidents who are ineligible for SSNs can use ITINs to comply with tax obligations, claim certain tax credits (when eligible), and establish a tax record — but these records do not translate into SSA benefit entitlements unless the person later obtains lawful work authorization and a valid SSN [2] [3]. The separation between ITIN and SSN is a recurring theme in government and nonprofit guidance because ITINs were explicitly designed to bring tax-reporting compliance without altering immigration or employment law status [6].
3. Real-world complications: payments, false numbers, and benefit records
The reality on the ground shows that some undocumented workers pay payroll taxes using false or stolen SSNs; the SSA credits those payments to the number’s recorded owner, not to the undocumented worker, and such tax contributions do not create legal entitlement to benefits without proper immigration status and valid SSN registration [4]. Recent reporting and SSA explanations note that even if taxes have been paid, benefit eligibility hinges on lawful work history under an authorized SSN and on meeting the program’s contribution and legal-status criteria. This creates complex situations for individuals who later regularize status: prior contributions may or may not be credited toward benefits depending on whether records can be validated and whether lawful employment and SSN linkage can be established [7] [4].
4. Exceptions, agency discretion, and narrow nonwork pathways
SSA guidance allows narrow exceptions where an SSN may be assigned for nonwork purposes when required by federal law or a state agency — for example, when an SSN is necessary to receive a specific federally funded benefit or to meet another legal requirement. Even then, applicants must show identity and document the legal need via a letter from the requesting agency; such exceptions are limited, administratively controlled, and do not equate to work authorization or Social Security benefit eligibility [1]. Analysts and SSA documents emphasize that these provisions are administrative accommodations, not pathways to Social Security retirement or disability benefits absent subsequent lawful work authorization and proper contribution history.
5. Bottom line for policymakers, immigrants, and advocates — practical implications
The consistent body of guidance across SSA and tax-policy sources presents a clear policy structure: SSNs for work require DHS authorization; ITINs permit tax compliance only; benefits require lawful contributions under an authorized SSN [1] [2] [5]. Stakeholders advocating for changes — from expanded access to benefits to pathways for undocumented workers — face a system where legal status and work authorization are the gatekeepers. Any policy proposals aiming to alter access to Social Security numbers or benefits would require statutory or regulatory changes affecting both DHS immigration authority and SSA eligibility rules; until such changes occur, the practical distinction between SSN and ITIN remains decisive for undocumented immigrants [3] [7].