Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Fact check: How many US citizens were wrongly deported in 2022?
Executive Summary
Between the sources provided, there is no definitive figure for how many U.S. citizens were wrongly deported in 2022; reporting and government reviews document wrongful deportations and detentions across multiple years but offer only aggregated counts for 2015–2020 or case-by-case details for later incidents. The most concrete government-backed total in these materials is 70 deportations of U.S. citizens identified from FY2015 through Q2 FY2020, while separate reporting documents hundreds of arrests and detentions of potential citizens and several high-profile wrongful deportation cases after 2020 [1] [2].
1. Big Number, Different Windows — Why 2022 Isn’t Isolated but Unquantified
The documents supplied emphasize systemic problems across multi-year spans rather than isolating 2022 as a discrete dataset. A Government Accountability Office–style summary in the materials tallies 674 arrests, 121 detentions, and 70 deportations involving potential U.S. citizens from FY2015 through Q2 FY2020, and advocates and reporters have used that multi-year window to highlight persistent errors [2]. Separate 2022 reporting details numerous ICE actions affecting potential citizens and notes individual wrongful detentions, but the reporting does not produce a standalone total for persons wrongly deported in calendar year 2022, leaving the question unanswerable from these sources alone [2] [3].
2. Case Files Tell a Human Story — From Individual Settlements to High-Profile Errors
Individual cases in the supplied material illustrate the stakes when systems fail: one 2022 report covered a U.S. citizen detained by ICE who later received a $150,000 settlement, showing that wrongful detention—not only deportation—has tangible legal and financial consequences [2]. Later reporting from 2025 highlights Kilmar Abrego Garcia’s wrongful deportation to El Salvador and administrative acknowledgment by ICE, demonstrating that such errors continued beyond 2020 and drew national attention [4] [5]. These narratives underline systemic error plus concrete human cost, but they are case-based rather than aggregate annual counts.
3. Research Across Decades Signals Recurring Patterns, Not Yearly Totals
Analyses of older detainers and enforcement data reveal recurring database errors, mistaken identity, and procedural lapses: one research piece covering 1999–2018 identified 155 detainers issued for U.S. citizens, including many born in the U.S. or Mexico, establishing an historical pattern of erroneous targeting by immigration enforcement [3]. This multi-decade framing explains why journalists and watchdogs rely on aggregated or cumulative statistics instead of single-year figures: the problem is dispersed over time and across agencies, complicating the generation of an authoritative count specifically for 2022.
4. Divergent Frames: Government Acknowledgment vs. Advocacy Reporting
The supplied materials show a split in emphasis: watchdog and news reports foreground cumulative statistics and systemic failures to press for reforms, citing hundreds of arrests and dozens of deportations across multi-year windows [1] [2]. Government statements, when present, acknowledge specific errors—such as ICE’s admission in Abrego Garcia’s case—but often frame responses around legal or security rationales rather than producing comprehensive admissions of past wrongful deportations in a given year [4] [5]. This divergence reflects differing agendas: advocacy seeks systemic accountability, while agencies emphasize case-level context and legal considerations.
5. What the Records Do Provide: Reliable Multi-Year Benchmarks
Although an exact 2022 tally is absent, the materials offer reproducible benchmarks useful for context: 70 deportations of U.S. citizens identified between FY2015 and Q2 FY2020 and 155 detainer incidents involving U.S. citizens from 1999–2018 are concrete figures present in the reporting and research cited [2] [3]. These benchmarks show the scale of the problem over time and justify scrutiny of post-2020 cases like the 2025 wrongful deportation to El Salvador; they also imply that isolated annual measurements require official, year-specific disclosure that the supplied sources do not include.
6. Bottom Line and Data Gaps — What Would Resolve the Question for 2022?
To answer “How many U.S. citizens were wrongly deported in 2022” with authority one would need an ICE- or DHS-published, year-by-year dataset that flags deportations later determined to involve U.S. citizens, or a GAO/Inspector General audit explicitly covering calendar year 2022. The supplied sources do not contain that year-specific tabulation; they provide multi-year totals, case reports, and post-2020 incidents that demonstrate the phenomenon but cannot be aggregated into a definitive 2022 count without additional official data [1] [2] [4]. Absent that disclosure, researchers must rely on cumulative benchmarks and case studies to assess the scope of wrongful removals.