Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Fact check: Number of Deaths in America from guns categorized as Murder
Executive Summary
The central claim is that in 2023 the United States recorded 46,728 gun-related deaths, of which 38% [1] [2] were categorized as murders, and that recent years show a modest decline in the national gun homicide rate after pandemic-era increases. Multiple reports note the U.S. remains an outlier internationally for firearm homicides, with age-adjusted rates many times higher than comparable high-income countries (published September 2025) [3] [4] [5].
1. What the headline numbers say and why they matter
Two pieces of the supplied reporting present a headline tally: 46,728 gun-related deaths in 2023 with 17,927 homicides, calculated as 38% of the total. That figure comes from a September 11, 2025 write-up summarizing research-center data and is presented as a direct count of gun-involved fatalities in the United States [3]. The same reporting notes a 14% decline in gun murders since 2021, which frames 2023 as part of a downward shift after the pandemic spike. These numbers are consequential because they drive policy debates and media coverage, and the absolute and proportional splits (suicides, accidents, homicides) underpin differing policy responses.
2. How public-health reporting frames the recent trend
A CDC-centered summary dated September 11, 2025 highlights that the national gun homicide rate fell in 2022 for the first time since the pandemic began, offering a public-health lens that treats year-to-year rate changes as signals of shifting risk [5]. The CDC framing emphasizes rates rather than raw counts, which matters because population changes and age adjustments affect interpretation. The CDC-sourced reporting is used here to contextualize the Pew-derived 2023 counts, indicating that the decrease in homicide rate observed in 2022 may have continued into 2023, consistent with the reported 14% decline since 2021 [5] [3].
3. The international comparison that sharpens the contrast
A September 16, 2025 analysis characterizes the United States as an outlier among high-income countries: the age-adjusted firearm homicide rate is 33 times higher than Australia and 77 times higher than Germany [4]. That comparison aligns with the broader claim that firearm homicide is unusually common in the U.S., and it is used to underscore that domestic declines in homicide rates do not change the fact that relative international risk remains far higher. The emphasis on age-adjustment is important because it neutralizes demographic differences when comparing nations.
4. Consistency and overlap across the supplied sources
The three supplied snippets overlap in substance and timing: a Pew-data summary (Sept 11, 2025) supplies the 46,728/17,927 breakdown and the 14% decline since 2021; CDC reporting (Sept 11, 2025) highlights a rate decline in 2022; and an outlier-analysis piece (Sept 16, 2025) compares U.S. rates with other wealthy democracies [3] [5] [4]. The two duplicate clusters (p2_s1–p2_s3) restate the same points. Taken together, these sources present a consistent narrative: high absolute and relative homicide burden, but recent downward movement in homicide rates after pandemic increases.
5. What the data do not fully resolve or omit
The supplied analyses omit several important breakdowns that would sharpen interpretation: they do not detail the age, geographic, or intent distribution beyond the homicide share, nor do they show whether the 14% decline is uniform across cities, states, or demographic groups [3] [5]. The pieces also do not reconcile how classification changes, reporting lags, or intent coding might affect the homicide share of gun deaths. These omissions matter because policy prescriptions often depend on whether declines are driven by policing, community interventions, changes in illicit markets, or statistical artifacts.
6. Potential agendas and how they shape emphasis
The Pew-centered summary and the outlier comparison each serve different communicative goals: one emphasizes the scale and recent decline of U.S. gun murders to inform domestic discussion, while the international-comparison piece highlights the exceptional nature of U.S. firearm homicide rates to press for broader systemic explanations [3] [4]. Both selections of facts are valid, but they steer readers toward different implications—either incremental progress domestically or persistent structural failure relative to peers—so readers should note the framing choices.
7. Bottom line: what is established and what remains to check
Established by the supplied reporting is that 46,728 people died of gun-related injuries in 2023, with 17,927 classified as murders, and that a decline in gun homicide rates was observed in 2022 and continues into a post-2021 downward trend amounting to a cited 14% reduction in murders since 2021 [3] [5]. What remains to check—using data not included here—is the subnational patterning, year-to-year methodological consistency, and how intent coding or demographic shifts contributed to the changes. These gaps determine whether the decline reflects sustained public-safety improvements or short-term fluctuations [3] [5].