Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Fact check: What is the current national average murder rate in the United States as of 2025?
Executive Summary
As of late 2025, public analyses converge on a notable decline in the U.S. murder rate, with multiple independent trackers and analysts projecting 2025 to be the lowest recorded year in decades; estimates center around roughly 4.4–5.0 murders per 100,000 residents, depending on assumptions and FBI revision processes [1] [2] [3] [4]. Discrepancies arise from different baselines and whether provisional mid‑year data are extrapolated or adjusted against the FBI's formal annual reporting and historical revisions, so the precise official figure will depend on the FBI’s finalized publications [1] [3].
1. Why multiple sources claim a sharp drop — and why they differ
Several contemporaneous reports document a large year‑over‑year decline in homicides through mid‑2025, with one real‑time tracker showing a 15–20% fall through July and analysts extrapolating that to an annual figure that would set a new low [1]. Differences between estimates stem from methodology: some analyses use provisional city and state reports aggregated in near‑real time, while others model seasonality and population changes or apply corrections based on past FBI revisions. The FBI’s formal annual report has a revision process that can materially change final rates, so immediate projections can diverge from the later official number [3] [4].
2. The headline numbers analysts are citing and how they were derived
Published estimates in September–October 2025 place the likely 2025 murder rate in the low‑to‑mid 4s per 100,000 or just at 5.0 per 100,000, down from about 5.17 in 2024 [2] [4]. One analyst’s projection cited a modeled 4.38 per 100,000 assuming a 15% drop and an adjusted 2024 baseline; others point to mid‑year patterns suggesting a 20% drop that would also produce an all‑time low if sustained [3]. These figures rely on extrapolating partial‑year counts and applying population denominators; the FBI’s finalized rate may differ after agency verification and revisions [1].
3. What the FBI’s revision process means for the final figure
The FBI historically revises preliminary violent‑crime statistics, sometimes adjusting earlier years’ counts as late reports arrive. Analysts caution that preliminary real‑time drops may be enlarged or reduced when the FBI completes its reconciliation and classification checks [1] [3]. The FBI reported a murder and nonnegligent manslaughter rate of 5.0 per 100,000 in 2024, and analysts are projecting a lower 2025 number; however, the final official 2025 rate will depend on the FBI’s year‑end reporting cadence and any upward or downward revisions to 2024 that shift comparative percentages [4].
4. Historical context: how dramatic is the change?
Analysts place the 2025 decline in the context of a long‑term downward trend from the early 1990s peak of 10.7 per 100,000 in 1991 to a pre‑pandemic low around 4.7 in 2014, followed by a spike during the pandemic era and a return toward lower levels in 2024–2025 [2]. If 2025 reaches the mid‑4s per 100,000, it would represent not only a sharp year‑over‑year decrease but also a continuation of a multi‑year recovery toward historically low homicide rates. That trajectory matters for policy debates about policing, prevention, and firearm violence, but exact policy implications depend on localized patterns as well as national averages [2].
5. Local variability and why national averages mask realities
While national averages point to a decline, city‑level and regional trends remain heterogeneous, with some urban areas showing pronounced falls and others persisting at higher rates [5]. Reports on specific cities like San Francisco and Baltimore underscore that national figures can obscure concentrated violence in particular places; analysts warn against treating the national average as a uniform improvement across all communities. Policymakers and journalists must therefore balance the headline national decline with subnational data to understand where interventions remain most needed [5].
6. Who is reporting these trends and what their incentives might be
The projections come from a mix of independent crime analysts, news outlets using real‑time trackers, and the FBI’s official statistics; each has different incentives and methodological limitations. Independent trackers emphasize timeliness and trend detection, which can highlight rapid improvements but risk instability in provisional numbers, while the FBI prioritizes completeness and classification accuracy, which can lag but yields final authoritative rates [1] [3] [4]. Readers should note these trade‑offs when interpreting an estimated 4.4–5.0 per 100,000 range for 2025.
7. Bottom line and what to watch for next
The best synthesis of current analyses is that 2025 appears on track to be the lowest U.S. murder rate recorded in recent history, with plausible estimates clustered around 4.4–5.0 murders per 100,000, contingent on final FBI revisions [1] [3] [2]. The precise official figure will be confirmed when the FBI publishes its finalized 2025 data and any retrospective adjustments to prior years. Watch for the FBI’s year‑end report and subsequent methodological notes that explain any revisions, and monitor city‑level releases to understand where the national decline is most and least pronounced [4] [5].