What kinds of primary government records constitute proof of U.S. naturalization and where are they filed?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
Primary government records that prove U.S. naturalization include the Declaration of Intention (first papers), the Petition for Naturalization (second papers) which usually contains the Oath of Allegiance/certificate, and the court-issued Certificate of Naturalization or Certificate of Citizenship; those records were created and filed in a mix of local, state, and federal courts and — depending on date — duplicated into federal holdings (C‑Files) or consolidated into Alien Files (A‑Files) held by USCIS and the National Archives [1] [2] [3].
1. What the core documents are: declarations, petitions, oaths, and certificates
The documentary trail of becoming a U.S. citizen is typically threefold: an immigrant first filed a Declaration of Intention (“first papers”), later filed a Petition for Naturalization (“second papers”) which records the court’s action and usually includes the Oath of Allegiance, and the court issued a Certificate of Naturalization or Certificate of Citizenship as the formal proof of status — these documents together constitute primary proof of naturalization [1] [4] [5].
2. Where courts filed the originals: a patchwork by era and jurisdiction
Before federal standardization in 1906, any court of record (municipal, county, state, or federal) could naturalize someone and those original records stay in the court or county clerk’s files; after 1906 federal regulation required copies be forwarded to the federal agency, and after 1917 more naturalizations were handled by U.S. District Courts, so holdings depend on whether the action was local, state, or federal [3] [6] [7].
3. What the federal government kept: C‑Files, A‑Files, and INS/USCIS holdings
From September 27, 1906, through March 31, 1956, duplicate copies of court naturalization records were filed in Certificate Files (C‑Files) that USCIS/INS retained; beginning April 1, 1956, naturalization records were incorporated into a subject’s Alien File (A‑File), and INS administrative records and indexes (now part of NARA holdings) also document naturalizations and related correspondence [3] [2] [8].
4. Where researchers and citizens go to obtain proof or replacements
For historic research, the National Archives’ regional facilities hold federal court records and many microfilm series and finding aids; USCIS Genealogy provides access to C‑Files and A‑Files and will accept FOIA or genealogy requests, and individuals needing a replacement certificate apply directly to USCIS — state and county clerk offices or judicial archives remain the primary repositories for pre‑1906 and many local filings [9] [8] [5] [10].
5. Practical realities: incompleteness, duplicate filing, and locating scattered records
Records can be incomplete (some petitions omit the oath or certificate), may be split between where the declaration was filed and where the petition was granted, and federal duplicates don’t cover every locale — researchers often must search county clerk offices, state judicial archives, the National Archives regional branch for the federal district, and USCIS indexes; commercial aggregators (Ancestry, Findmypast) host many digitized images but are derivative of these public collections and charge access [1] [7] [11] [12].
6. Hidden seams and alternate views: agency changes and why provenance matters
Because jurisdiction over naturalization shifted repeatedly (state courts acting as federal agents, then centralized federal handling under INS, later USCIS), provenance affects legal and genealogical certainty — some historians and genealogists emphasize county clerk searches first for pre‑1906 cases, while federal indexes and USCIS files are indispensable for 1906–present cases; agencies also caution that historic records are preserved “as created” and cannot be altered by archives staff, which matters for anyone seeking corrections or replacements [13] [3].