What federal rules govern the release of USCIS naturalization records for deceased individuals and how have they been applied previously?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
Federal rules for releasing USCIS naturalization records of deceased individuals are governed primarily by the agency’s genealogical regulations and implementing Code of Federal Regulations provisions that treat genealogy requests as searches for records of deceased persons, set a 100‑year presumption of death based on birth date, and require documentary proof when that presumption does not apply [1] [2] [3]. In practice, USCIS’s Genealogy Program operates as a fee‑for‑service channel that will release historical C‑Files and other designated series without FOIA/Privacy Act processing when all named individuals in a file are proven deceased, while records created after certain cutoff dates generally must be sought through FOIA/Privacy Act channels [4] [5] [6].
1. What the rules actually say: genealogy requests, presumptions and proof
The regulations define “genealogy requests” as searches and/or copies of historical records relating to a deceased person and require requesters to provide specific identifiers such as full name, date of birth and place of birth when available [3] [1]. A key bright‑line rule in 8 C.F.R. §103.40 is that search subjects whose birth dates are more than 100 years before the date of request are presumed deceased, and in all other cases the subject is presumed living until the requester satisfies USCIS that the person is dead [2] [1]. When the presumption of death does not apply, documentary evidence—an obituary, death certificate, Social Security Death Index entry or similar proof—is required to convince the agency to treat the record as genealogical and release it under the Genealogy Program [7] [8].
2. What records the Genealogy Program covers and when FOIA is needed
USCIS authorizes its Genealogy Program to make five series of historical records available, notably Certificate Files (C‑Files) that include duplicate court naturalization certificates for the period September 27, 1906 through March 31, 1956, and certain A‑Files for arrivals and naturalizations consolidated on specified dates [5] [2]. The agency’s public guidance and research pages make clear that naturalization records on or after April 1, 1956 (and immigration records after May 1, 1951) fall outside the Genealogy Program’s routine scope and generally must be requested through the USCIS Freedom of Information Act/Privacy Act (FOIA/PA) program [9] [6].
3. How USCIS applies the rules in practice: release without FOIA when everyone is dead
USCIS states that if “all individuals identified in the file are proven deceased,” the file can be released without undergoing FOIA/Privacy Act processing—meaning the Genealogy Program will provide copies as a fee‑for‑service when the death requirement is met [4]. The agency also tells researchers that supplying proof of death up front can speed processing and that certain streamlined forms (e.g., Form G‑1041A) may be used to request just a naturalization certificate and avoid broader Privacy Act review when eligible [4] [8] [5]. These operational steps reflect the regulatory tension: genealogical access balanced against privacy protections for living subjects [1].
4. Practical consequences, limits and verification pathways
Because USCIS maintains duplicative court certificates and centralized records for the early–to‑mid 20th century, requesters searching those eras can often obtain records via the Genealogy Program if they meet the death evidence standard, but negative searches elsewhere (e.g., National Archives) do not negate USCIS’s exclusive authority over post‑1906 citizenship records and USCIS can issue a Certification of Non‑Existence when it finds no record [10] [5]. Where birth dates fall within 100 years of the request or records post‑1956 are sought, the FOIA/Privacy Act route remains the appropriate and often slower path because USCIS will presume subjects alive without satisfactory proof of death [2] [6].
5. Where reporting and practice can diverge: transparency and friction points
USCIS’s publicly posted rules and forms create predictable outcomes—presumption of death after 100 years, documentary proof otherwise, and designated cutoffs for Genealogy vs FOIA—but friction remains when files name multiple persons (requiring proof for all) or when requesters lack easy access to death documentation, leading to delays or FOIA referral despite genealogical intent [4] [7]. The official sources summarize the criteria and practical forms and fees but do not provide exhaustive case logs here, so assessments of how consistently USCIS applies these rules in every individual case are limited by available public guidance [5] [4].