Was renee good shot before impact with the officer

1. The video record shows shots as the SUV begins to move

A 47‑second cellphone clip from the ICE officer who fired shows Renee Good behind the wheel and, according to multiple reporting outlets that verified the footage, three gunshots occur as she turns the steering wheel and starts to drive away, immediately followed by the vehicle striking a parked car and a light post . Lawfare’s scene-by-scene description is explicit: “as Renee Nicole Good turns her steering wheel to the right and begins to drive away, three shots ring out, her vehicle careens into a parked car and light post” , which supports the reading that the shots coincide with the vehicle’s initial movement rather than only after a later impact.

2. Officials say the agent was struck, but timing is ambiguous

Department of Homeland Security officials and public statements from leaders including DHS Secretary Kristi Noem reported the agent was hit by Good’s vehicle and was treated at a hospital, with later reporting saying he suffered internal bleeding to the torso . Those official assertions establish that the agent sustained injuries from contact with the vehicle, but they do not, in the public record cited here, pin down whether that contact preceded the gunfire, occurred during the moments of the shooting, or followed it .

3. Independent reporting and expert parsing stress the limits of video alone

News organizations and analysts that have reviewed the footage caution that camera angles, frame rates, and partial perspectives complicate efforts to establish definitive milliseconds of sequence; CBC and BBC noted the new angle adds detail but “does not appear to be changing views about whether the use of force was justified,” and that the FBI and other agencies are still involved in investigations . Lawfare’s analysis points out tactical positioning — how other officers clustered near the driver’s door and how only one maintained a safer distance — which matters to assessing whether the agent reasonably perceived an immediate lethal threat when he fired .

4. Competing narratives and political claims affect how the sequence is portrayed

Federal officials and some national politicians have described Good as having “weaponized her vehicle” and said the agent was struck before he used force, framing the shooting as defensive . Advocates, family members, and many protesters view the footage as evidence that the shooting happened while Good was attempting to leave and was not a necessary use of deadly force; reporting and commentators have highlighted language and behavior by officers on the scene as relevant to that judgment . Both frames draw on parts of the record, but neither side has produced evidence in the public domain that definitively proves the exact chronology down to the key split-second.

5. What the public record can and cannot say now

Based on the videos published and verified by multiple outlets, the most supportable, evidence‑based statement is that the three shots were fired as Good’s vehicle began moving and before the vehicle came to rest after hitting a parked car — which means she was shot as the vehicle was in motion rather than only after a clear, later impact . At the same time, claims that the officer was struck by the vehicle and sustained internal injuries are corroborated by DHS and other officials, but the publicly available footage and official summaries do not definitively establish the micro-sequence of whether the officer was struck before the trigger pull; that question remains subject to the ongoing criminal and administrative investigations .