What specific quotes or writings of David Icke have been labeled antisemitic by watchdog groups?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
Watchdogs and critics have singled to specific Icke writings: his endorsement of the antisemitic forgery The Protocols of the Elders of Zion and passages in books such as The Robots' Rebellion , And the Truth Shall Set You Free and The Biggest Secret that name the Rothschilds and describe Jews in conspiratorial terms — claims described as antisemitic by sources including the Anti-Defamation League and historian commentators [1]. Wikipedia and multiple quote-aggregators document a passage attributing Jews to the “Rothschild altar of greed and lust for power” and describe Icke’s identification of the Rothschilds as reptilians; critics say he uses “Rothschild Zionist” language that maps onto historic antisemitic tropes [1] [2].
1. The Protocols endorsement: the red flag watchdogs cite
Icke’s endorsement of The Protocols of the Elders of Zion — a century-old antisemitic fabrication — is repeatedly raised by critics as a decisive example. Reporting notes Icke endorsed The Protocols in The Robots' Rebellion and in And the Truth Shall Set You Free ; that endorsement prompted his publisher to decline further books and is cited as a core reason watchdogs label his work antisemitic [1].
2. Naming the Rothschilds and “Rothschild Zionists” — classic antisemitic framing
Multiple sources quote Icke’s repeated focus on the Rothschild family and his use of the phrase “Rothschild Zionists,” presenting them as controlling world events. The Algemeiner-cited commentary and Community Security Trust commentary summarized on Wikipedia highlight his narrative that a “‘Rothschild Zionist’ conspiracy controls the world,” a trope with “a long history as an antisemitic theme” [1]. Critics say listing people in power as “Rothschild Zionists” effectively equates Jewish identity with conspiratorial global control [1].
3. Quotations flagged verbatim in public collections
Quoted lines attributed to Icke appear in public quote collections and have been cited by critics: for example, a passage reported on Goodreads states, “The Jewish people have been sacrificed on the Rothschild altar of greed and lust for power…” — a formulation watchdogs point to when describing his work as antisemitic [2]. Such explicit language naming Jews in terms of greed and control is central to why groups like the ADL say “there is no fair reading” of Icke’s work that isn’t antisemitic [1].
4. Reptilian code: alleged dog-whistle or literal claim?
Icke’s reptilian framework — that certain elites are shape-shifting reptilian beings — has been interpreted by some critics as a coded antisemitic device when he identifies the Rothschilds among those elites. Wikipedia notes critics argue his identification of the Rothschilds as reptilians may operate as a deliberate “code” for Jews; Icke has denied that intent, but watchdogs still cite the overlap between his conspiratorial tropes and historic antisemitic themes [1].
5. Institutional reactions and labels
The Anti-Defamation League’s then-chief executive Jonathan Greenblatt is quoted saying that Icke’s corpus “could not be seen as not anti-Semitic,” a direct institutional judgement reported on Wikipedia and cited by other coverage [1]. The publisher reaction to his use of The Protocols and other contested material is another concrete institutional response documented in reporting [1].
6. What the available sources do not cover or confirm
Available sources do not provide a comprehensive, line-by-line list of every Icke sentence labeled antisemitic by specific watchdogs; they document representative flagged passages (endorsement of The Protocols, Rothschild/Rothschild‑Zionist formulations and the “Rothschild altar” quote) and broader assessments by organizations and commentators [1] [2]. No source in the provided set supplies a primary-text excerpt from And the Truth Shall Set You Free beyond the Protocols endorsement, nor do they include Icke’s full rebuttals to each antisemitism charge in these excerpts [1].
7. Competing viewpoints and limitations
Icke and some supporters reject the antisemitism label; Wikipedia notes Icke denies using “reptilian” tropes as a code for Jews, and public collections include quotes where he distinguishes Zionism from Judaism (e.g., “Many Jews are not Zionists and many non-Jews are” appears on quote sites) [3]. But watchdogs argue his repeated linkage of Jewish families and Zionism to global cabals and his endorsement of The Protocols outweigh those statements [1] [3]. The material available in these sources is selective and mediated — quote sites, Wikipedia summaries and secondary commentary — so a definitive forensic inventory would require consulting primary texts from Icke’s books and full statements from watchdog reports, which are not present in the provided collection [1] [2].
Conclusion — what to take away
The publicly cited examples that watchdogs and critics point to are narrow and specific: endorsement of The Protocols; naming the Rothschilds as drivers of global events and characterizing Jews in conspiratorial terms (including the “Rothschild altar” line); and the use of “Rothschild Zionist” language. These passages are the core textual basis for labels of antisemitism in the sources provided [1] [2]. For a thorough, source-by-source adjudication you would need the primary book texts and the full statements of the watchdogs themselves; those documents are not included in the current reporting [1].