Did Elon Musk perform a Nazi salute or gesture in public?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
Video from a January 20, 2025 inauguration rally shows Elon Musk place his right hand to his chest and then extend his right arm twice in an upward diagonal; many viewers and politicians called the motion a Nazi or fascist salute while some watchdogs and experts urged caution or defended him [1] [2]. Major outlets report that the gesture was widely interpreted as a Hitler or Roman salute in Europe and the U.S., while the Anti‑Defamation League described it as “an awkward gesture” and critics including historians called it clearly fascist [3] [2] [1].
1. What happened on stage — the visible gesture and immediate reaction
At a Capitol One Arena event tied to President Trump’s second inauguration, footage shows Musk tap his chest with his right hand and then extend his right arm with palm down at an upward diagonal, repeating the motion facing the crowd behind him; social media and news outlets quickly compared that posture to the Nazi “Heil” or fascist Roman salute [1] [4]. The action provoked instant online virality, with some users isolating the arm movement and others reposting the full clip including his words “My heart goes out to you,” which supporters say contextualizes the motion [2] [5].
2. Competing interpretations — deliberate salute, awkward motion, or something else
Conservative and far‑right voices embraced the reading that the gesture was an intentional fascist salute or a provocation; several European left‑wing politicians and commentators called for consequences and some argued it was unambiguous [6] [3]. By contrast, the ADL publicly said Musk “made an awkward gesture in a moment of enthusiasm, not a Nazi salute,” and urged restraint in interpreting intent — a view echoed by some who point to his spoken phrase and body language as alternative context [2] [1].
3. Why the debate matters — symbolism, context and who amplifies it
Scholars and commentators note that the Nazi salute has a specific historical form (outstretched right arm, palm down) and that modern extremists have continued to use it; its appearance on a political stage tied to a far‑right crowd made the symbol especially fraught and prompted European lawmakers to react strongly [1] [3]. At the same time, some defenders and onlookers argue that isolated video clips can mislead if they omit the words or preceding motion, which is why organizations such as the ADL cautioned against quick judgment [2].
4. How institutions and figures responded
The incident prompted a range of institutional responses: the ADL urged giving “a bit of grace” and characterized the motion as awkward rather than malicious; historians such as NYU’s Ruth Ben‑Ghiat called it a “very belligerent” Nazi salute; European politicians demanded action or criticized Musk; Musk reposted footage and later made jokes on X that some saw as flippant [2] [4] [7]. Media outlets documented both the condemnation and the defense, while Musk’s allies sought alternative framings, including a claim by an adviser that the gesture expressed “I want to give my heart to you” [6] [4].
5. What independent fact‑checking and deeper reporting found
Fact‑checkers and outlets documented the sequence of movement and the social media context, while noting that intent cannot be proved from a brief clip: Snopes concluded the gesture could plausibly be interpreted in multiple ways and that the meaning of Musk’s intent is unknowable from video alone [5]. AP reported that right‑wing extremists celebrated the gesture but reiterated that intention “wasn’t totally clear” and that some watchdogs warned against overreading the motion [2].
6. Limitations and what sources do not resolve
Available reporting establishes what the footage shows and how different actors interpreted it, but no source in the record proves Musk’s internal intent or offers a definitive admission that he meant to invoke Nazism; likewise, sources do not include a sworn statement by Musk directly acknowledging a deliberate Nazi salute beyond his reposting and joking posts on X [5] [2]. The public record therefore rests on visual evidence plus competing interpretations from experts, advocacy groups and politicians [1] [3].
7. Bottom line — evidence, interpretation and stakes
The clip plainly resembles the historical outstretched‑arm fascist salute and drew widespread condemnation and alarm across Europe and the U.S.; some institutions and historians say the gesture was a Nazi or Roman salute, while others — notably the ADL — advise caution and call it awkward enthusiasm [1] [2] [3]. Given that intent cannot be independently verified in the available reporting, the controversy will persist as a mix of visual evidence, political context and competing readings documented across major outlets [5] [4].