Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
What antisemitic remarks did Nick Fuentes make in 2019 and where were they recorded?
Executive summary
Nick Fuentes made repeat antisemitic statements in 2019 that included minimizing the Holocaust through a grotesque Cookie Monster analogy — questioning whether six million Jews could have been killed by asking if the Cookie Monster could bake that many cookies — and other comments denying or disparaging Jewish loyalty to the United States. Reporting at the time places those remarks in public appearances and online broadcasts, notably a controversial campus speech at Iowa State University and interviews/podcasts that were recorded and published online [1] [2]. The record is uneven: some summaries identify the content and sites of the remarks, while other documents in the collection lack direct transcripts or precise recording details, meaning primary video/audio review is necessary to fully verify context and exact wording [3] [4] [5].
1. How the Cookie Monster line became shorthand for Fuentes’s Holocaust minimization
Contemporaneous reporting from December 2019 captured Fuentes using a mocking, rhetorical device that equated the Holocaust death toll to an implausible cookie-baking task, a line widely cited as an effort to minimize or question six million Jewish deaths. Journalistic accounts frame the remark as emblematic of his approach: using irony and coded jokes to express antisemitic ideas while attempting plausible deniability. That reporting attributes the Cookie Monster analogy to Fuentes’s public commentary in 2019 and documents backlash from other conservative figures who called out the remark as overt bigotry rather than a clever provocation [1]. Those pieces provide a dated record of the comment and the immediate reactions but stop short of supplying complete video transcripts in the materials provided here.
2. Where the 2019 remarks were recorded: campus events and online broadcasts
Available material identifies at least one in-person speech in 2019—an Iowa State University appearance—that provoked controversy and was reported by local outlets. Coverage describes Fuentes making antisemitic gestures and comments during that campus event, and notes that the speech was recorded and circulated online; a separate item points to a YouTube recording cited as the ISU speech [2] [4]. Beyond campus appearances, Fuentes’s pattern in 2019 included interviews and live-stream formats—his own shows, podcasts, and appearances on other channels—where similar themes appeared. Several analyses here refer to Infowars and other online programs from 2019 as venues for his remarks, though the supplied snippets do not contain full transcripts or uniformly labeled timestamps [5] [4].
3. Discrepancies in the record and gaps that need primary-video review
The assembled sources display inconsistency: some pieces explicitly name the Cookie Monster analogy and link it to 2019 reporting, while other documents provided in this packet contain no relevant content or only code and metadata, and one source explicitly lacks the quoted material. These disparities mean the secondary summaries are reliable for establishing that antisemitic remarks were made and widely reported, but they are not substitutes for primary recordings when assessing exact phrasing, tone, or context. The materials point to specific digital traces—YouTube uploads and Infowars/podcast episodes—but the excerpts here do not include embedded transcripts or preserved timestamps, so independent verification by viewing the cited recordings is necessary to confirm exact language and placement [3] [5] [4].
4. Who documented and who condemned the comments — reading intent and agenda
Coverage of Fuentes’s 2019 remarks comes from a mix of local campus reporting, Jewish media and mainstream outlets, and peer conservative commentators, creating competing frames: some narratives emphasize deliberate white-nationalist strategy masked as irony, while others focused on immediate campus disruption and distancing by established conservative organizations. This patchwork of sources reflects differing agendas: advocacy organizations and Jewish outlets highlighted antisemitic content and threat narratives, while some conservative interlocutors framed the remarks as provocations or tried to marginalize Fuentes. The materials provided show both condemnation and explanation, but the core factual claim—that Fuentes made Holocaust-minimizing and antisemitic comments in 2019 that were recorded—is consistently reported across these pieces [1] [2].
5. Bottom line and what to check next if you need airtight verification
The evidence assembled here establishes that Nick Fuentes uttered antisemitic remarks in 2019, including the Cookie Monster Holocaust-minimization analogy, and that those comments appeared in recorded formats: campus speeches (Iowa State) and online interviews/podcasts. To move from well-supported summary to airtight citation, review the primary videos and transcripts linked or noted in the reporting—specifically the identified YouTube upload of the ISU speech and the 2019 podcast/Infowars episodes—so you can cite exact timestamps and wording. The current set of analyses confirms the substantive claims while also revealing gaps in direct transcript availability within this packet, underscoring the need to inspect original recordings for full context [4] [5] [2].