Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
What were the top-ranked trustworthy news outlets in 2024 surveys?
Executive Summary
The most consistent finding across the provided 2024 surveys is that outlets focused on non-political service or public broadcasting—The Weather Channel, BBC, and PBS—ranked highest in net trust, while sensational and partisan outlets like the National Enquirer, Infowars, and Breitbart sat near the bottom on net trust measures [1] [2]. Major legacy local and national news organizations—local TV, traditional newspapers, ABC, CBS, NBC, and The New York Times—also registered solid trust ratings in 2024, even as partisan divisions and differing methodologies produced varying top lists across surveys [3] [4]. Below I compare the key claims, note methodological and partisan caveats, and show what the different 2024 polls actually measured and omitted.
1. Why weather and public broadcasters top the charts — unpacking YouGov’s net-trust calculus
YouGov’s 2024 audience-net-trust metric showed The Weather Channel leading by a wide margin, followed by the BBC and PBS, with net trust scores reported as +43, +25, and +22 percentage points respectively; The Wall Street Journal tied near PBS in some measures [1]. The metric counts the share saying “trustworthy” minus the share saying “untrustworthy,” which privileges apolitical, service-oriented brands that are used daily and rarely judged through a political lens [1] [2]. That explains why a non-news service like Weather performs best repeatedly; the same YouGov series reported The Weather Channel as most trusted in 2022–2024 and again in the 2025 follow-up referencing 2024 perceptions [2]. The reliance on net-trust percentages accentuates consensus around low-conflict providers rather than deep evaluative judgments of investigative journalism.
2. Local TV and legacy newspapers: trusted by habit and proximity
Another prominent 2024 finding is that local TV stations and newspapers scored highest on straightforward “trust” ratings, with 62% and 58% saying they trusted those categories in a YouGov question focused on institutional trust rather than brand net scores [3]. This measure captures habitual reliance and perceived local accountability—trusted because they cover community issues and immediate emergencies. The contrast between the net-trust ranking (which lifts nonpolitical brands) and the simple trust percentage (which favors local outlets) shows how question wording and sampling affect “top-ranked” conclusions, and it explains why national legacy brands like ABC, CBS, and NBC appear repeatedly as trusted even when they don’t top net-trust league tables [3].
3. National legacy outlets and the fragmented “most trusted” lists ahead of the 2024 election
Pew Research’s September 2024 data on top sources of political news found Fox News and CNN as the most-cited single outlets for political news, with Fox cited by 13% and CNN by 10%, while local TV and major networks also ranked importantly [4]. That metric measures where people go for political information, which is not identical to generalized trust scores: many Americans rely on outlets they see as biased but useful for coverage. The Poynter/PolitiFact guidance and other journalistic compilations listed similar national names—NYT, Washington Post, NPR—when advising reliable sources for election coverage, reflecting professional assessments rather than simple public trust tallies [5].
4. Who’s mistrusted: tabloids, conspiracy outlets, and partisan asymmetry
YouGov’s net-trust list placed National Enquirer (-44), Infowars (-18), and Breitbart (-13) among the least trusted outlets in 2024 [1]. Surveys also recorded a sharp partisan gap: Democrats tended to rate more outlets as trustworthy than Republicans did, while Republicans were more likely to classify mainstream sources as “liberal.” That asymmetry shapes which outlets appear near the bottom or middle of any ranking depending on the partisan composition of the sample [1]. This partisan overlay means “least trusted” lists often reflect political identity and selective exposure, not just journalistic quality.
5. Big-picture caveats: methodology, question wording, and international context
Comparing the sources shows different questions produce different winners: net-trust (YouGov) elevates neutral utility brands; percent-trust (YouGov) elevates local TV and newspapers; source-of-political-news (Pew) elevates high-consumption political brands like Fox and CNN [1] [3] [4]. International measures and broad trust indexes (Statista, Edelman referenced in the dataset) show country-level trust fluctuations that are not the same as outlet-by-outlet rankings and therefore can mislead if conflated with the U.S. brand lists [6] [7]. The surveys collectively underscore that “top-ranked trustworthy outlets” depends on metric, audience, and political lens, a critical framing often omitted when headlines assert a single definitive ranking.