Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Which Pope named Leo commented on Donald Trump and what was the exact quote?
Executive summary
Pope Leo XIV — identified in reporting as the current pope and the first U.S.-born pontiff — has publicly criticized President Donald Trump’s immigration policies, calling the treatment of foreigners in the United States “extremely disrespectful” and urging humane treatment and reflection [1] [2]. Multiple outlets quote him telling reporters that “we have to look for ways of treating people humanely, treating people with the dignity that they have,” and that treating long-resident migrants harshly is “extremely disrespectful” [3] [4].
1. Who is “Pope Leo” and why does his voice matter?
Pope Leo XIV is presented in the reporting as the first U.S.-born pope and a pontiff whose relative proximity to American politics has amplified the significance of his remarks; that background helps explain why his comments on U.S. immigration policy are widely covered [2] [5]. Journalists and analysts note that when a pope speaks clearly on a U.S. policy issue it can put moral pressure on American Catholics and political actors, a dynamic Reuters and BBC pieces explicitly describe [5] [6].
2. What exactly did Pope Leo XIV say about Trump and migrants?
Contemporaneous accounts repeat two core lines. First: the pope endorsed U.S. bishops’ rebuke of immigration raids and said the bishops’ statement was “very important” [1] [3]. Second: when asked about migrants he said “we have to look for ways of treating people humanely, treating people with the dignity that they have,” and described the treatment of many who’d lived in the U.S. for years as “extremely disrespectful” — wording picked up across Reuters, Fox News, The Daily Beast and others [1] [3] [4]. The New York Times’ summary adds that Leo invoked Scripture: “Jesus says very clearly … how did you receive the foreigner?” reflecting his pastoral framing [7].
3. Did he explicitly name Donald Trump?
Available reporting frames Leo’s remarks as criticism of the Trump administration’s immigration policies rather than a personalized attack on Trump’s person; articles repeatedly link the pope’s words to the administration’s mass deportation and raid tactics [1] [8]. Reuters and The Guardian, among others, describe the comments as a criticism of the administration’s approach, saying foreigners “are being treated in a manner that was ‘extremely disrespectful’” [1] [2]. The sources do not quote a one-line direct address like “Donald Trump is…” — they report Leo criticizing the administration’s policies [1] [8].
4. What exact phrase is consistently reported?
The phrase that recurs verbatim in multiple outlets is that migrants and foreigners in the U.S. were being treated “extremely disrespectful(ly)” and that “we have to look for ways of treating people humanely, treating people with the dignity that they have.” Reuters, Fox News, The Daily Beast and The Guardian all reproduce these turns of phrase in their coverage [1] [3] [4] [2].
5. How have outlets framed the political implications?
Analysts and opinion pieces differ: some see Leo as a moral counterweight who could shame or influence U.S. politics, with The Guardian and The Atlantic suggesting he could pressure Trump and his supporters; others report that his comments have cost him some favor with conservative Catholics who had welcomed his early tone [9] [10] [5]. Reuters and BBC emphasize institutional effects — the U.S. bishops’ conference issuing a rebuke and local clergy feeling emboldened — rather than immediate policy change [11] [5].
6. Disagreements and limits in the record
Sources agree Leo criticized the administration’s immigration actions and used the words included above, but they vary in emphasis. Opinion pieces (The Guardian, NYT, Atlantic) interpret broader political significance and compare Leo to predecessors [9] [7] [10]. Hard news stories (Reuters, BBC) stick to his quoted lines and document institutional reactions [1] [6] [8]. No source in the provided set prints a different exact quote that directly addresses Donald Trump by name with a single-line soundbite; rather reporting situates the pope’s language as criticism of the administration’s policies [1] [3].
7. Short reading list to verify and widen context
For concise reporting of the remarks and immediate fallout, see Reuters (straight reporting of the quote and bishops’ statement) and BBC (context and reaction) [1] [6]. For interpretive pieces that place Leo’s words in U.S. politics and Catholic debates, consult The Guardian, The New York Times and The Atlantic [9] [7] [10]. For U.S. local consequences and meetings that followed, the Chicago Tribune and Reuters pieces are useful [12] [11].
Conclusion: multiple reputable reports identify the speaker as Pope Leo XIV and consistently quote him urging humane treatment of migrants — “we have to look for ways of treating people humanely, treating people with the dignity that they have” — and calling some recent practices “extremely disrespectful,” framed as criticism of the Trump administration’s immigration policies [1] [3] [4].