Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Fact check: Is Alberta introducing or passing a bill to become independent of Canada and join the US?
1. Summary of the results
Alberta is NOT introducing a bill to become independent or join the US. Instead, Bill 54 is being introduced to lower the threshold for citizen-led referendums from 20% to 10% of voters [1]. Premier Danielle Smith has explicitly stated she is not a separatist and believes in "Alberta sovereignty within a united Canada" [1]. While the bill makes it procedurally easier to trigger referendums, it does not itself declare independence or propose joining the US [1].
2. Missing context/alternative viewpoints
Several important contextual elements are missing from the original question:
- There is an active separatist movement, with the Commonwealth of Alberta Delegation working towards establishing independence by December 2025 [2]
- Approximately 37% of Albertans have expressed interest in sovereignty [2]
- The Republican Party of Alberta's leader Cameron Davies is promising "hundreds of townhalls to promote a divorce from Canada" [1]
- Polls show 30% of Albertans might support separation if the Liberal Party wins another election [3]
- Political columnist Graham Thomson describes separation as a "pipe dream" used to inflame rhetoric against the federal government [1]
3. Potential misinformation/bias in the original statement
The original question suggests a direct link between government action and independence/US statehood, which misrepresents the situation in several ways:
- The discussion of US statehood is actually being used as a strategic negotiation tactic to gain leverage with Ottawa, rather than a serious proposal [4]
- While separatist sentiment exists, it's primarily driven by opposition groups and citizen movements, not the current provincial government [1]
- The bill in question (Bill 54) is about democratic reform and citizen initiatives, not separation [1]
Those who benefit from promoting the separation narrative include:
- Opposition politicians like the Republican Party of Alberta, who use it to build support
- The Commonwealth of Alberta Delegation, seeking to establish an independent state
- The provincial government, which can use separation threats as leverage in negotiations with the federal government [4]