Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Fact check: Did Biden give illegals social security
Executive Summary
President Biden has not enacted a policy that broadly grants Social Security benefits to undocumented immigrants; federal law and recent administration actions point toward restricting benefit access to unauthorized noncitizens rather than expanding it. Undocumented immigrants typically cannot receive Social Security benefits, although many pay payroll taxes that contribute to the system; a presidential memorandum from April 15, 2025, specifically directed actions to prevent illegal aliens from obtaining Social Security Act benefits [1] [2]. The debate mixes tax contributions, eligibility rules, and state-level programs, creating political confusion that fuels the claim.
1. Why the Claim Emerged — Taxes, Contributions, and Misread Policies
Public confusion stems from two concurrent facts: many undocumented workers pay payroll taxes while federal eligibility for benefits generally requires lawful status. Analysts estimate undocumented workers contributed substantial payroll taxes—about $26.2 billion in 2023—supporting Social Security’s finances [2] [3]. This reality is often presented out of context as "undocumented people get benefits," but paying into the system is not the same as eligibility for benefits. Federal rules and agency procedures require documentation of legal status or work authorization during benefit applications, which prevents routine award of Social Security benefits to those without lawful status [4] [5].
2. The Administration’s Formal Direction — A Clear Restriction in April 2025
A salient policy document is a presidential memorandum dated April 15, 2025, that directs the Social Security Administration to prevent illegal aliens from obtaining Social Security Act benefits. This memorandum is an explicit federal-level instruction to restrict benefit access and undercuts claims that the Biden administration has given Social Security to undocumented immigrants en masse [1]. The memorandum’s publication date anchors the administration’s stance in spring 2025 and indicates federal policy priorities that contradict the original statement.
3. How the Social Security Administration Actually Verifies Eligibility
The Social Security Administration’s application process requires documentation verifying identity, legal status, and work authorization for noncitizens. Eligibility routines involve checks that generally bar unauthorized immigrants from receiving federal Social Security benefits, although exceptions and complexity exist for other programs like Medicare or disability where prior work credits matter [4] [5]. The agency’s procedures make it operationally challenging for undocumented individuals to obtain ongoing Social Security retirement or survivor benefits absent lawful presence or qualifying work histories.
4. Contrasting Voices and Political Framing — Why Messaging Diverges
Different reporting and political actors frame the issue to serve narratives: immigration advocates emphasize payroll tax contributions as evidence of immigrants’ role in supporting Social Security, while opponents highlight legal ineligibility and federal memos to argue against benefit access. This partisan framing often omits technical distinctions between paying taxes, eligibility for contributory benefits, and eligibility for non-contributory benefits, producing misleading short claims that "Biden gave illegals Social Security" [3] [6].
5. State-Level Programs and Federal Limits — The Important Omitted Detail
Some states have adopted programs that extend certain public benefits to undocumented residents, but federal Social Security benefits are distinct and generally governed by national law. Migration policy analyses note unauthorized immigrants are typically excluded from federally funded public benefits, though states can create limited programs for healthcare or welfare that complicate public perception [7]. The omission of state-versus-federal differences in many popular claims amplifies confusion about what the federal government can or did change under the Biden administration.
6. What Facts Are Firm and What Remains Nuanced
Firm facts: federal law and SSA procedures generally bar unauthorized immigrants from Social Security benefits, undocumented workers contribute payroll taxes, and a presidential memorandum on April 15, 2025, reinforced restrictions [1] [2]. Nuances: contributions by undocumented workers do support the Trust Fund modestly, and certain eligibility scenarios—such as mixed-status families, prior lawful work, or state-level programs—can blur outcomes for individuals. Understanding both the legal rules and fiscal contributions is essential to evaluate specific claims.
7. Bottom Line for the Original Statement — Accurate or False?
The statement "Did Biden give illegals social security" is misleading. There is no evidence that the Biden administration enacted a policy granting Social Security benefits to undocumented immigrants broadly; federal action in April 2025 directed agencies to prevent such awards, and administrative procedures require legal-status verification [1] [4]. The claim likely conflates payroll tax contributions and state-level benefit programs with federal Social Security eligibility, producing a simplified and incorrect impression of federal policy [2] [7].