Have any Canadian prime ministers or premiers held dual citizenship in the past?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
Yes: at the federal level, a small number of Canada’s prime ministers and federal political leaders have held citizenship ties to other countries in the past — most clearly former prime minister John Turner, who retains British citizenship, and a spate of modern controversies involving leaders such as Andrew Scheer and figures like Thomas Mulcair — while Canada’s law does not bar dual citizens from serving as MPs or prime minister [1] [2] [3].
1. Historical context: why “foreign‑born” doesn't always mean dual citizen
Several early prime ministers were born outside what is today Canada — John A. Macdonald, Alexander Mackenzie and Mackenzie Bowell among them — but the modern legal category of “Canadian citizenship” did not exist until 1947, so being born in the United Kingdom or elsewhere in the 19th century does not map neatly onto contemporary dual‑citizenship rules [2].
2. A confirmed example: John Turner and a living precedent
John Turner, who served briefly as prime minister in 1984, continues to hold U.K. citizenship and is explicitly identified in reporting and parliamentary backgrounders as a former prime minister with dual citizenship, making him the clearest, documented federal example [1] [4].
3. Modern controversies: Scheer, Mulcair and political optics
Contestation over dual nationality has surfaced repeatedly in modern politics: Andrew Scheer’s U.S. citizenship became campaign fodder in 2019 and raised questions about renunciation timelines, and Thomas Mulcair was publicly criticised by political rivals over his dual citizenship; those episodes illustrate that while dual citizenship is legally permissible, it remains politically sensitive and can be weaponized in campaigns [3] [5] [4] [6].
4. The law and practice: no legal bar but a political test
Canadian election law and practice do not disqualify members of Parliament or prime‑ministerial candidates for holding more than one citizenship; commentators and experts cited in reporting emphasize that unlike some countries, Canada imposes no constitutional prohibition on dual nationals holding federal office, so the issue is one of perception and politics rather than legal eligibility [3] [6].
5. Premiers (provincial leaders): reporting is sparse on documented cases
The reporting provided does not offer clear, sourced examples of provincial premiers who have held dual citizenship, so it is not possible on the basis of these sources to affirmatively list premiers with documented dual nationality; available coverage focuses largely on federal politicians and historical prime ministers rather than provincial premiers [3] [2] [1].
6. What this means: legal permissibility versus political risk
Taken together, the record in the supplied reporting shows that dual citizenship among federal leaders has occurred and is lawful — John Turner is the concrete historical instance, and recent figures such as Scheer and Mulcair show the political consequences — but whether a politician chooses to renounce a second nationality often reflects calculations about optics and vulnerability rather than legal necessity [1] [4] [3] [6].