Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
What were Charlie Kirk's exact comments about Melissa Hortman?
Executive summary
Available reporting shows wide circulation of many of Charlie Kirk’s controversial public remarks after his September 2025 killing, but the provided sources do not quote a single, definitive “exact comment” he made specifically about Melissa Hortman; instead they document that Kirk made inflammatory statements broadly and that commentators and outlets compared reactions to Kirk’s death with responses to the June murder of Minnesota’s former House speaker Melissa Hortman [1] [2] [3]. Fact-checkers and news outlets note social-media claims that Republicans failed to condemn the Hortman killing were false or misleading and cite specific republican condemnations, while opinion pieces debate the differing public responses [4] [2] [5].
1. What the sources actually record about Kirk’s words
The sources assembled here collect many of Charlie Kirk’s public, often incendiary remarks and compile them after his assassination — including racist, sexist, and provocative lines made onstage and on his show — but none of the provided articles give a direct, attributable “exact comment” by Kirk about Melissa Hortman herself; coverage instead catalogues his broader rhetoric and controversial quotes [1] [6] [7]. Fact-checking and quote-collection outlets pictured in the results focus on Kirk’s public record at large rather than a single Hortman-specific statement [6] [7].
2. Why Melissa Hortman’s name appears in the post-shooting coverage
Hortman’s murder in June became a flashpoint in September debate about partisan reactions to political violence: commentators and columnists compared the public and political responses to the two killings — Kirk’s and Hortman’s — to argue either that there was inconsistent attention or that critics were weaponizing tragedy for partisan points [2] [5]. That debate, rather than a documented direct quote about Hortman from Kirk, is what repeatedly surfaces in the headlines and opinion pages [2] [5].
3. Claims about Republican reactions and what fact-checkers found
After Kirk’s death, social posts claimed “not a single Republican condemned” the assassination of Melissa Hortman; FactCheck.org investigated and found that claim false, noting several Republicans — including former Minnesota governor Tim Pawlenty and former president Donald Trump — did make public remarks related to the cases, and that other figures did offer condolences [4]. FactCheck.org specifically flags a viral X post as wrongly stating blanket non-condemnation by Republicans [4].
4. Examples of media and opinion framing on both tragedies
Opinion writers and outlets used both events to make broader arguments. The New York Times opinion piece framed Kirk’s assassination as an attack on democratic discourse and listed Hortman among other political victims, using the two killings to argue for the basic safety of political actors [2]. Conversely, media commentary and essays questioned disparities in memorials, coverage, and public reaction between Kirk and Hortman, suggesting uneven national attention and political amplification [5] [8].
5. Republican figures’ specific responses highlighted in coverage
Some outlets singled out individual Republican responses for contrast: The Guardian noted Senator Mike Lee’s quick public condemnation of Kirk and recalled that Lee had previously amplified conspiratorial tweets after the Hortman killings, producing pushback and accusations of double standards [3]. That reporting is used to illustrate how reactions from the same public figures can be read differently depending on timing and context [3].
6. Limitations and what the sources don’t say
Available sources do not provide an explicit, attributable quote from Charlie Kirk about Melissa Hortman; they do not document Kirk commenting directly on Hortman’s murder in the pieces supplied here [1] [2] [6]. If you are seeking the verbatim phrase Kirk allegedly said about Hortman, current reporting in this set does not include such a quotation — it contains broader compilations of his remarks and coverage of reactions to both killings [1] [6] [7].
7. How to proceed if you need a verbatim quote
To locate any exact remark by Kirk about Hortman (if it exists), review primary sources cited in quote collections — transcripts of The Charlie Kirk Show, social-media posts from his verified accounts, or the archives used by Media Matters and Snopes — because the summaries and opinion pieces in these search results do not reproduce a specific Hortman-directed quote [1] [6]. Fact-checkers’ and news outlets’ rundowns are helpful for context but are not substitutes for primary-source verification [4] [6].
Bottom line: the reporting collected here shows extensive cataloguing of Kirk’s provocative public record and robust debate about unequal public responses to political violence, but these sources do not provide an exact, attributable Charlie Kirk quotation about Melissa Hortman [1] [4] [2] [6] [3] [5].