Fact check: Does Danielle smith want Alberta to join the USA

1. Summary of the results

Based on the analyses provided, there is no evidence that Danielle Smith wants Alberta to join the USA. All sources consistently indicate that this claim is not supported by available evidence.

The analyses reveal that Smith has taken a diplomatic approach to US relations, particularly with the Trump administration, which has generated controversy ^[1]. Her appearances on Fox News and perceived friendliness with the US have sparked negative reactions, with critics calling her a "traitor" and suggesting she should move to the US ^[2]. However, these criticisms stem from her diplomatic engagement, not from any stated desire for Alberta to join America.

Regarding Alberta separatism, Smith has acknowledged that "Albertans' desire for leaving Canada has never been higher" ^{[3] [4]}. However, her response has been to work with the federal government to address these concerns, not to pursue joining the USA. Her Alberta Next Panel specifically aims to create "an Alberta that is strong, free and sovereign within a united Canada" ^[5].

2. Missing context/alternative viewpoints

The original question lacks important context about Smith's actual positions and the broader political dynamics at play:

• Energy sector interests: Smith's pro-US stance appears driven by Alberta's energy sector needs, particularly since the oil and gas industry has significant American corporate involvement ^[6]. This suggests her approach may be economically motivated rather than politically separatist.
• Conservative political strategy: Smith has expressed preference for a Conservative government in Ottawa, believing it would have better working relationships with US administrations ^[7]. This indicates her focus is on federal Canadian politics rather than leaving Canada.
• Controversial associations: Smith has shared platforms with figures like Ben Shapiro, who has suggested Canada could be annexed by the US without voting rights for Canadians ^{[8] [9]}. While this doesn't reflect Smith's own views, it provides context for why some might question her loyalties.
• Tariff concerns: Smith's comments about tariffs and US trade relationships demonstrate her focus on protecting Alberta's economic interests within the existing Canadian framework ^[7].

3. Potential misinformation/bias in the original statement

The original question appears to contain an unfounded assumption. The phrasing "Does Danielle Smith want Alberta to join the USA" presupposes that this is a legitimate possibility or that there's credible evidence supporting such a claim.

The analyses suggest this narrative may be politically motivated misinformation designed to damage Smith's reputation. Critics who call her a "traitor" for engaging diplomatically with the US ^[2] and those who suggest she's "prioritizing American interests over Canadian ones" ^[6] appear to be using inflammatory rhetoric rather than factual assessment.

The question also ignores Smith's explicitly stated commitment to Canadian unity. Her separatist concerns are framed as problems to be solved within Canada, not as stepping stones toward joining another country ^[5]. This suggests the original question may reflect partisan political attacks rather than genuine policy analysis.