How many Americans have been killed by illegals in 2025
Users have flagged this fact-check as potentially inaccurate. Read critically and verify claims independently.
Executive summary
There is no single, authoritative national tally of how many Americans were killed by people described as “illegal aliens” in 2025; federal agencies and independent researchers say comprehensive, reliable nationwide data on homicides by immigration status do not exist in the public record [1] [2]. Political and departmental statements list specific victims and incidents — for example DHS highlighted named 2025 victims at ceremonial events and the VOICE office was relaunched to serve families — but those lists are not presented as an exhaustive, verifiable national count [3] [4] [5].
1. Why the simple number the question seeks does not exist in official statistics
Federal law enforcement and public-health statistics do not publish a routine, validated national dataset enumerating homicides by a suspect’s immigration status, and fact-checkers and researchers have repeatedly warned against unverified annual totals circulated on social media; Reuters specifically found “no evidence” for claims that undocumented immigrants kill 4,000 Americans a year and noted the absence of nationwide data by immigration status [1] [2].
2. What the government and advocacy outlets do publish — and what those publications actually show
DHS press releases and the relaunched VOICE office publicize individual cases and pay tribute to victims of crimes committed by noncitizens, listing high-profile 2025 incidents (including traffic deaths and violent murders), but these accounts are case-based narratives used to make policy and political points rather than a statistically validated total for the year [3] [4] [5].
3. Independent research context: crime rates by immigration status
Multiple peer-reviewed and policy analyses show that immigrants — including unauthorized immigrants — are not more likely to commit homicide than native-born Americans and in many studies have lower offending or conviction rates; the Brennan Center and academic studies cited by Reuters and other outlets find either similar or lower rates among immigrant groups [1] [6] [2].
4. How political actors attempt to turn incident lists into policy arguments
Senators and administration officials have leveraged documented 2024–2025 cases to propose new criminal statutes and to expand tools such as the death penalty in crimes involving noncitizens, and legislation and press releases from lawmakers list individual murders as justification for tougher measures — demonstrating how incident compilations are used politically even when comprehensive national data are not available [7] [3].
5. Detentions and deaths in custody are a related but distinct metric
Reporting shows that ICE custody deaths spiked in 2025 — The Guardian and other trackers report dozens of deaths in ICE detention that year — but deaths of people in ICE custody are not the same as “Americans killed by illegals” and do not provide a count of U.S. citizens murdered by noncitizen suspects [8] [9].
6. Bottom line and what can be cited with confidence
Based on the sources reviewed, a precise national number answering “How many Americans have been killed by illegals in 2025?” cannot be produced: federal data systems do not publish a validated nationwide homicide total by immigration status, reputable fact-checkers warn against widely circulated large estimates, and available government documents and political statements provide episode lists rather than a comprehensive tally [1] [2] [3]. Journalistic and scholarly practice therefore requires acknowledging this data gap rather than asserting an uncertain aggregate.