When was the last time the Democratic Party gerrymandered in any state
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Was this fact-check helpful?
1. Summary of the results
Based on the analyses provided, the Democratic Party has engaged in gerrymandering in recent years, though the sources do not provide a specific "last time" date. The evidence shows that Democrats have gerrymandered in several states:
- Illinois, New Mexico, and Oregon - where Democrats drew maps during recent redistricting cycles [1] [2]
- Maryland - involved in an extreme gerrymander case that reached the Supreme Court six years ago alongside a Republican case from North Carolina [3]
- Nevada - mentioned as a state where Democrats redistricted "just as ruthlessly as Republicans" [2]
The sources indicate that both parties engage in gerrymandering practices [4], with Democrats drawing maps "in a few places" during the 2024 election cycle [1]. However, none of the analyses provide a definitive answer to when the Democratic Party "last" gerrymandered, as this practice appears to be ongoing in various states where Democrats control the redistricting process.
2. Missing context/alternative viewpoints
The original question lacks important context about the ongoing and bipartisan nature of gerrymandering. Key missing perspectives include:
- Scale and frequency comparison: While Democrats do gerrymander, the sources suggest Republicans may engage in the practice more extensively - one analysis notes that "both sides don't gerrymander the same" [4]
- Strategic considerations: Eric Holder, Chairman of the National Democratic Redistricting Committee, has suggested Democrats may need to "change their approach and potentially gerrymander in Democratic-controlled states like California and New York in response to the GOP's efforts" [5]
- Institutional constraints: The sources indicate that in states with redistricting commissions, Democrats are "checked" from gerrymandering, but where they aren't constrained by such institutions, they engage in the practice [2]
Political operatives and party leaders benefit from framing gerrymandering as either a one-sided problem or a necessary defensive strategy, depending on their partisan position.
3. Potential misinformation/bias in the original statement
The original question contains an implicit assumption that may be misleading - by asking "when was the last time" the Democratic Party gerrymandered, it suggests this is a past practice rather than an ongoing one. The evidence shows that gerrymandering by Democrats is not a historical artifact but a current practice in states where they control redistricting [1] [2].
The framing could also minimize the complexity of redistricting politics by seeking a simple timeline rather than acknowledging that gerrymandering occurs cyclically during redistricting periods (typically every 10 years after the census) and varies by state control and institutional constraints.
Republican strategists would benefit from promoting the narrative that Democrats regularly gerrymander to justify their own practices, while Democratic leaders might benefit from downplaying recent instances to maintain moral authority in criticizing Republican gerrymandering efforts.