Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
What did Donald Trump say in 2013 interviews about a potential government shutdown?
Executive Summary
In 2013 Donald Trump publicly argued that a government shutdown would be remembered as a mark on the sitting president and that presidential leadership — not Congress — would be blamed if a shutdown occurred; he told interviewers the president must “get people together” and that “problems start from the top” [1] [2]. Multiple fact‑checks and contemporaneous reports confirm this thrust while noting that widely circulated short quotes are often paraphrases rather than verbatim lines attributed to him [3] [4].
1. What Trump actually said — phrasing that sticks and what’s unproven
Reporting and fact‑checks identify interviews in 2013 in which Trump emphasized that a shutdown would reflect poorly on the president and that the president bears responsibility for resolving it. In one appearance he said, in substance, “the president’s the leader and he’s got to get everybody in a room and he’s got to lead,” adding that “problems start from the top and they have to get solved from the top”; outlets identified this remark in September 2013 Fox & Friends coverage and similar comments on NBC’s Today [2] [5]. Independent fact‑checks caution that meme‑style quotes circulating later — for example, the neat sentence “A government shutdown falls on the president’s lack of leadership” — are not verbatim in the record, even though they capture his meaning [3] [4]. Contemporary tweets from Trump in 2013 also attempted to shift blame to President Obama on budget decisions, underscoring a mix of attributing fault to presidential leadership while politicizing congressional dynamics [5] [2].
2. How contemporaneous press framed his remarks and context that matters
News outlets in 2013 and subsequent retrospectives framed Trump’s comments as part of a broader debate over who would be blamed if budget talks collapsed. Journalistic accounts recorded Trump saying a shutdown would be “a tremendously negative mark on the president” and stressing the historical memory of a shutdown would center on the president, not congressional leaders [6] [5]. Fact‑check reporting emphasized the contrast between Trump’s generic point about leadership responsibility and later political uses of truncated quotes to suggest absolute responsibility. Those fact‑checks documented that while Trump repeatedly voiced that presidents are judged for shutdowns, he also publicly blamed President Obama on policy grounds in tweets, showing he was both commenting on leadership norms and engaging in partisan attribution [5] [1].
3. Why precise wording matters — memes versus primary sources
Multiple verification pieces note that the most viral one‑liners attributed to Trump about shutdowns are condensed paraphrases rather than transcripts; accuracy demands distinguishing his general assertion about presidential responsibility from a neat, singular quote that circulates later [3] [4]. Fact‑checkers who reviewed archived interviews and transcripts found phrases matching the paraphrase but not the exact tidy sentence attributed to him. This distinction matters because political actors and social media often treat shorthand memes as direct quotations, which can amplify claims that are technically unsupported by the primary evidence even while reflecting the speaker’s intent [2] [3].
4. Multiple viewpoints: critics, supporters and neutral assessors
Critics used Trump’s 2013 comments to argue he acknowledged presidential responsibility for shutdowns and later acted differently when he faced shutdowns as president, framing that as inconsistency; neutral fact‑checkers documented the earlier remark and compared it to his later tweets and statements, underscoring the difference between principle and partisan messaging [1] [7]. Supporters could point to his 2013 emphasis on presidential leadership as evidence he understands executive responsibility. Fact‑checks and news reports present both angles: the substance of his claim about leadership is supported by primary interviews, while the more crystalline version of the quote is not verbatim in the record [8] [3].
5. Bottom line: what a careful reader should take away
A careful reading shows that Donald Trump did publicly assert in 2013 that a government shutdown would be a mark on the sitting president and that the president must lead to prevent it, remarks documented in interviews and contemporaneous coverage; however, the widely shared short quote claiming he said a shutdown “falls on the president’s lack of leadership” in that exact wording cannot be verified as a verbatim line and appears to be a consolidated paraphrase [5] [2] [3]. Consumers of political claims should rely on archived interviews and credible fact‑checks for precise wording and avoid equating paraphrase memes with direct quotations, since the distinction affects assessments of consistency and accountability [4] [1].