Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Loading...Time left: ...
Loading...Goal: $500
Fact check: How do federal programs like Medicare, Medicaid, and defense spending affect the tax contribution versus spending balance by state?
Checked on June 11, 2025
1. Summary of the results
Federal spending shows a clear dominance of health and social programs in the national budget. Specifically:
- Medicare and Medicaid combined account for $1.339 trillion in spending [1]
- Medicare alone represents $839 billion, or 52% of mandatory health spending in FY2024 [2]
- Over 25% of federal spending goes to health programs, with Medicare accounting for 36% of total federal health support [2]
- Entitlement programs as a whole consume 50% of federal spending as of 2023 [3]
2. Missing context/alternative viewpoints
The original question overlooks several crucial aspects:
*Budget Structure:
- Federal spending is divided into mandatory and discretionary categories
- Mandatory spending represents nearly two-thirds of annual federal spending and doesn't require annual congressional approval [4]
- Federal health spending is 70% mandatory, 19% tax subsidies, and 11% discretionary [2]
Current Political Context:
- Budget reconciliation discussions are currently focused on potential cuts to Medicare, Medicaid, and ACA programs to offset expiring tax cuts [2]
- These potential cuts could significantly impact low-income populations' access to healthcare [2]
Other Major Spending Categories:
- Social Security ($1.2T)
- Non-defense discretionary spending ($910B)
- Defense Department ($751B)
- Net interest ($475B) (all from p3_s2)
**3. Potential misinformation/bias in the original statement**
The question's framing might lead to oversimplified conclusions about federal spending:
Complexity of Programs:
- The question treats defense spending as equivalent to health programs, but they operate under different budgetary rules and mechanisms
- Healthcare programs are primarily mandatory spending, while defense is discretionary [4]
Stakeholder Interests*:
- Low-income populations have the most to lose from potential cuts to these programs [2]
- Political interests benefit from framing the discussion around "tax contribution versus spending balance" rather than social outcomes
- The growing proportion of spending on entitlement programs is projected to exceed other priorities like national defense [3], which could influence future policy debates
Want to dive deeper?
Which states receive more federal funding than they contribute in taxes?
How does defense spending distribution affect red state versus blue state economics?
What is the net fiscal impact of Medicare and Medicaid on different states?
Do wealthy states subsidize poorer states through federal tax and spending policies?
How has federal spending redistribution between states changed over the past decade?