Which former U.S. presidents have faced criminal investigations or indictments and what were the outcomes?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
Donald J. Trump is the first former U.S. president to be criminally indicted, facing multiple federal and state prosecutions whose outcomes remain subject to ongoing litigation and trial scheduling [1] [2] [3]. Earlier presidents have come close or faced non‑criminal consequences—most notably Richard Nixon, who escaped criminal charges after a likely indictment was averted by a presidential pardon, and Bill Clinton, who faced civil litigation and impeachment but not criminal indictment [4] [5] [1].
1. Donald J. Trump — the historic indictments and their status
Donald Trump has been charged in several distinct criminal matters at both state and federal levels, including allegations tied to alleged hush‑money payments in New York, mishandling classified documents, attempts to overturn the 2020 election culminating in the January 6 indictment, and state charges in Georgia; these multiple prosecutions make him the first former president ever criminally indicted [2] [1] [3]. The indictments differ by jurisdiction and charges, trials are scheduled or pending, and advocacy groups and trackers continue to catalogue counts and statuses as courts resolve pretrial and evidentiary disputes [2].
2. Richard Nixon — a resignation, a near‑indictment, and a pardon
Richard Nixon never faced a criminal indictment because he resigned amid Watergate and then received a full pardon from his successor, Gerald Ford, which removed the prospect of prosecution for offenses related to his presidency; archival materials later revealed a “would‑be” indictment drafted by Watergate investigators listing charges such as bribery, conspiracy and obstruction [4] [5] [6]. While many of Nixon’s associates were convicted or pleaded guilty, the pardon shut off the possibility of Nixon’s own criminal trial and remains the definitive outcome of his legal exposure [5].
3. Bill Clinton — civil litigation, impeachment, but no criminal charge
Bill Clinton’s legal entanglements—most prominently the Paula Jones civil suit and the Monica Lewinsky revelations—produced civil damages and led to impeachment in the House, though Clinton was not criminally indicted for actions tied to those episodes and he completed his presidency without criminal prosecution [1] [6]. The Supreme Court’s decision in Clinton v. Jones affirmed that presidents can face civil suits for unofficial acts predating office, a legal backdrop that contributed to the impeachment but not to criminal charges [1].
4. Ulysses S. Grant and other historical footnotes
Ulysses S. Grant was once brought into custody on a relatively trivial charge—speeding while riding in his horse carriage—and fined, an early example of a president formally encountering the criminal process without broader political scandal or prosecution for serious wrongdoing [6]. Aside from these examples, authoritative legal summaries note that no other U.S. president or former president had been criminally charged prior to Trump, though several administrations produced investigations or indictable conduct by subordinates [6].
5. The legal debate: immunity, precedent, and political pressure
Legal authorities and institutional players remain divided on whether and when a sitting or former president should be criminally prosecuted: Justice Department opinions have argued that a sitting president enjoys immunity from criminal prosecution for official acts, while many legal scholars accept the possibility of indicting former presidents for conduct outside constitutional authority or for private crimes [3] [6]. Recent events have also highlighted how prosecutorial appointments and political aims can complicate cases—reporting on controversial appointees and disqualified prosecutors underscores how prosecutions tied to political actors can be litigated on procedural grounds as well as merits [7].
6. Conclusion — outcomes and continuing uncertainty
The practical answer is narrowly focused: Donald Trump stands alone as the first former president criminally indicted, with cases pending and outcomes unresolved [1] [2]; Richard Nixon avoided criminal charges because of Gerald Ford’s pardon after a probable indictment was contemplated [4] [5]; Bill Clinton faced civil liability and impeachment but no criminal indictment [1]; and Ulysses S. Grant had a minor arrest and fine [6]. Beyond these concrete instances, constitutional, prosecutorial and political questions mean that future encounters between former presidents and criminal courts will continue to test legal doctrines and institutional norms [3] [6].