Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Giorgia meloni is delivering every promises made during campaign
Executive Summary
Giorgia Meloni has fulfilled some campaign pledges while falling short or leaving others incomplete; she is not delivering “every” promise. Evidence shows clear follow-through on measures such as tougher immigration enforcement and proposals for constitutional change, while other pledges — on broad tax cuts, comprehensive family policy delivery, and some human-rights related outcomes — remain mixed or contested [1] [2] [3]. This analysis synthesizes available evaluations and reporting to map which promises have measurable progress, which are partial, and which lack sufficient evidence of completion.
1. Border Control Wins and Human Costs: What Meloni Delivered and What Stayed Problematic
The government implemented a hardline migration stance that produced a measurable drop in migrant arrivals by boat in 2024 compared with earlier years, signaling delivery on the campaign promise to crack down on irregular migration; analyses highlight this as a demonstrable policy outcome [1]. At the same time, experts and reporting emphasize that maritime deaths and humanitarian consequences remain a serious unresolved problem, which complicates claims of unequivocal success and raises questions about the ethics and effectiveness of the methods used. Observers who track arrivals and mortality point to a reduction in arrivals but continued fatalities, meaning policy delivery on “fewer arrivals” is clear while human-impact objectives are not [1]. Critics frame the approach as punitive and potentially violating international obligations, while supporters underscore restored control and electoral fulfilment [1] [4].
2. Constitutional Reform and Institutional Ambition: A Concrete But Partial Achievement
Meloni’s government advanced a draft law to pursue constitutional reform aimed at changing the election method for the prime minister, aligning with an explicit campaign pledge to alter executive selection. The proposal and legislative steps show active pursuit of institutional reform, meeting the definition of delivering on that specific promise [3]. However, passage of constitutional change requires broader parliamentary and possibly referendum support, so proponents stress progress and intent while opponents point to democratic safeguards and political motive concerns. The record thus reflects measurable delivery in initiating reform but not yet final constitutional ratification, leaving the pledge partially fulfilled rather than conclusively completed [3] [5].
3. Domestic Policy Scorecard: Select Passes Amid Many Incomplete Promises
Analysts compiling a scorecard of Meloni’s first years find mixed results: initiatives to support families and promote “Made in Italy” show some positive movement, while flagship pledges such as sweeping immigration halts or immediate large-scale tax overhauls register as failed or in-progress [2]. Fact-based inventories indicate the administration has converted several campaign items into policy actions — particularly those with clear legislative or regulatory levers — but many campaign promises were broad, expensive, or politically contested, producing uneven implementation. The heterogeneous performance suggests a government selectively delivers where institutional capacity, budgetary space, or political coalition support permit, but cannot be said to have implemented every promise across the platform [2] [6].
4. Centerward Shifts and Foreign Policy Consistency: Delivering Unexpected Promises
On European and international affairs, Meloni has surprised observers by tacking to the center on key issues — reaffirming commitments to the EU, NATO, and support for Ukraine — contradicting expectations of radical divergence. This represents delivery on the implicit campaign signal of continuity in foreign policy, though it diverges from the more nationalist tenor of some campaign rhetoric [4]. Analysts note this creates both political capital with allies and accusations of inconsistency from domestic hardliners, illustrating a strategic choice to prioritize geopolitical alignment over certain nationalist pledges. The foreign policy record thus contains clear actions that qualify as delivered promises, while exposing tensions between campaign rhetoric and governance choices [4].
5. Press Freedom, Rule of Law, and the Limits of “Delivery” Claims
Several reports highlight concerns about press freedom and civil liberties under Meloni’s tenure, and these raise the issue that delivery on campaign pledges can conflict with other democratic commitments [6]. Some steps taken — regulatory, rhetorical, or administrative — have alarmed journalists and rights groups, suggesting that while the government may claim certain domestic-order promises delivered, this has sometimes entailed actions critics say undermine pluralism. Evaluations therefore separate technical fulfilment of campaign items from their broader societal impact: a fulfilled promise is not necessarily an unqualified public good. Diverse sources thus portray delivery as real in many domains while cautioning about trade-offs and unintended consequences [6] [2].
Conclusion: The record demonstrates selective delivery — clear, documented fulfilment of several prominent pledges alongside numerous partial, disputed, or unmet promises. The claim that Giorgia Meloni is delivering “every” campaign promise is not supported by the available evidence; instead, the evidence points to a government that advances certain priorities decisively while leaving other commitments incomplete or controversial [1] [2] [3].