Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
How many U.S. Capitol Police officers died by suicide in the months after January 6 2021?
Executive Summary
Three days after the January 6, 2021 attack on the U.S. Capitol, U.S. Capitol Police Officer Howie (Howard) Liebengood died by suicide, and subsequent reporting and official rulings have linked additional post‑Jan. 6 officer suicides to the riot response; contemporary reporting and later determinations indicate at least four officers who responded to January 6 later died by suicide, with some sources counting two of those as U.S. Capitol Police and others including Metropolitan Police officers in that total [1] [2] [3]. The precise labeling of those deaths as “line‑of‑duty” has been contested and evolved over time, producing divergent tallies and policy outcomes that lawmakers and families have used to secure benefits and to highlight first‑responder mental health needs [1] [4] [5].
1. How the immediate claim is framed and the count that circulates in media
Multiple contemporary and retrospective accounts converge on the assertion that four police officers who responded to the January 6 riot died by suicide in the weeks and months afterward, a figure that has been repeatedly cited in national coverage and advocacy by families and unions. Some reports explicitly identify two of those four as U.S. Capitol Police officers — Howard Liebengood and, in some recounting, another officer linked to Capitol response — while other reporting and compilations include two Metropolitan Police Department officers, Gunther Hashida and Kyle DeFreytag, in the same four‑officer total [2] [3]. The result is a commonly repeated number — four — that mixes agency affiliation in some accounts, producing variation in how many U.S. Capitol Police officers specifically are counted versus how many responding officers overall are included [2] [6].
2. Official rulings altered the narrative about “line‑of‑duty” status and benefits
The legal and administrative follow‑up changed the policy stakes: the Department of Justice and administrative boards have at times recognized certain suicides as line‑of‑duty deaths, most notably for Howard Liebengood under the Public Safety Officer Support Act mechanism enacted in 2022, a determination that enabled benefits for his family and set a precedent for claims tied to traumatic on‑duty experiences [1]. Other jurisdictions, such as the District of Columbia’s retirement board, have separately ruled that Jeffrey L. Smith’s death was a line‑of‑duty death, while Washington law historically excluded suicide from line‑of‑duty designations, creating inconsistent classifications that shaped both compensation and public counts [6] [4].
3. Disputes, family perspectives, and the limits of public counting
Families and some officials dispute precise characterizations and the reach of causal attributions; Jeffrey L. Smith’s widow has at times disputed the manner of death noted in some reports, and reporting has acknowledged that partisan conflict and recordkeeping practices may obscure the “true” tally of deaths linked to January 6 in the public imagination [7] [1]. Advocates and bereaved relatives have pushed for recognition and benefits precisely because classification matters practically and symbolically, and media accounts show how those advocacy efforts helped shift legal outcomes even as some agency records lagged or used different definitions [1] [4].
4. What reputable outlets and officials actually report about the number
Major outlets and official boards have consistently reported that four responding officers died by suicide following the riot, but they differ on whether to categorize all four as U.S. Capitol Police or to combine Capitol Police and Metropolitan Police Department personnel in that total; for example, reporting from 2021 and 2022 lists four officer suicides tied to the event while distinguishing the agencies involved in narrative text [2] [5]. The most corroborated reading across the sources provided is that at least two U.S. Capitol Police officers and at least two Metropolitan Police officers who responded later died by suicide, yielding the four‑officer figure most often cited, with agency‑specific counts varying by source [3] [6].
5. Broader context: policy response, mental‑health risk, and what’s omitted
Reporting emphasizes broader patterns: law enforcement officers face elevated suicide risk compared with the general working population, and the aftermath produced legislative changes such as the Public Safety Officer Support Act of 2022 prompted in part by families’ activism and DOJ determinations that recognized some suicides as in the line of duty [1]. Important omissions in public discourse include systematic, centralized recordkeeping that disaggregates agency, ruling status, and timeline; the lack of a single, consistent official registry means counts rely on media compilations, administrative rulings, and family advocacy, which explains persistent variation and why some outlets report agency‑specific numbers while others report an overall four‑officer total [4] [5].