How many illegals have been arrested by ICE and deported?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
ICE and DHS reporting and independent trackers show deportations in 2025 have surged: DHS has announced figures ranging from “more than 400,000” to 527,000 removals in under a year, while the Department later said “more than 2 million” people have left the U.S. including an estimated 1.6 million voluntary departures and 527,000 formal removals [1] [2]. Independent analysts estimate ICE itself carried out roughly 340,000 removals in FY2025 and note a major rise in interior arrests by ICE that has not always matched prior-year deportation trends [3] [4].
1. The headline numbers: conflicting official claims vs. independent estimates
DHS press releases provide the largest, most politically propelled totals: a September DHS release said “two million illegal aliens have left” including “more than 400,000” deportations, and an October release asserted “more than 527,000” removals [1] [2]. Independent research groups and policy shops offer lower but still large estimates: the Migration Policy Institute estimated ICE conducted about 340,000 deportations in FY2025 — a figure derived from public records and modeling rather than a single agency proclamation [3]. Time and other outlets note deportations were stable earlier in 2025 even as ICE arrests rose sharply, suggesting a lag between arrests and removals [4].
2. Arrests versus removals: why numbers don’t map neatly
ICE and DHS have dramatically increased interior arrests — Reuters reported internal targets of up to 3,000 arrests per day — but higher arrest counts do not automatically equal instant deportations. MPI and Time explain removals lag because of court processes, voluntary departures, and logistics; MPI specifically found ICE conducted more deportations from U.S. communities in FY2025 than Border Patrol apprehensions at the southern border for the first time since at least 2014 [3] [4] [5].
3. What “deported” actually includes in DHS statements
DHS statements have mixed categories. Their “left the U.S.” framing counts formal removals plus voluntary self-deportations; the September release credited 1.6 million voluntary departures and “more than 400,000” deportations within the 2 million total [1]. That blending inflates public-facing tallies compared with academic estimates that isolate formal ICE removals and those ordered by courts [3].
4. ICE’s shifting enforcement priorities and the criminality question
The administration and DHS emphasize “worst of the worst” criminal removals in press releases, with repeated claims that 70% of ICE arrests are of people charged or convicted of crimes; DHS press releases list arrests of murderers, pedophiles and traffickers [6] [7] [8]. Independent reporting and analyses find a different mix on the ground: local datasets in San Diego and Northern California show a large share of ICE interior arrests involved people without criminal convictions — 58% in San Diego/Imperial counties and roughly half in Northern California in 2025 [9] [10]. Nationally, NBC reported ICE arrested nearly 75,000 people with no criminal records in the first nine months of 2025 [11].
5. Local operations and patchwork reporting complicate transparency
On-the-ground arrest tallies vary city-to-city. Minnesota operations yielded reporting of 12 to 19 arrests depending on outlet [12] [13]. The Guardian and other outlets reported DHS using vague terms like “dozens” in some local operations, making independent verification difficult [14]. Civil-society trackers (ICE Flight Monitor, StopICE.net, PIRC) have compiled flight and arrest data that suggest deportation flights and interior detentions surged, but these sources track different slices of activity and can’t fully reconcile with DHS totals (p2_s7; not provided).
6. Scale, capacity and political incentives
Several sources note capacity constraints and political pressure. Migration Policy Institute warned DHS lacked sufficient resources to instantly meet rhetoric about mass interior deportations even as detention populations ballooned and congressional funding expanded [15] [16]. Reuters and other outlets documented agency targets and altered tactics to meet newly ambitious arrest quotas [5]. DHS press releases and the White House have clear political incentives to showcase high removal numbers as signs of policy success [2] [1].
7. Limitations and what reporting does not settle
Available sources do not provide a single authoritative total that isolates how many people ICE alone arrested and then completed deportation for in 2025 without including voluntary departures or Border Patrol removals; DHS figures mix categories and independent estimates differ [1] [3]. Sources disagree on the share of arrestees who had criminal convictions: DHS emphasizes a high criminal share while local and national analyses show large percentages without convictions [6] [9] [11].
Takeaway: DHS claims of hundreds of thousands of removals in 2025 are supported by agency press releases that include voluntary departures, while independent analysts produce lower but still substantial ICE removal estimates. Arrest volume has clearly risen — sometimes dramatically — but translating arrests into completed deportations varies by data source, legal category and local reporting [2] [1] [3] [11].