Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Fact check: How many legal immigrants were deported by ICE in 2024?
Executive Summary
The most consistent, verifiable figure across government and media reporting is that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) removed roughly 271,000 noncitizens in fiscal year 2024, with precise tallies reported as 271,484 in ICE statements and corroborated by multiple news outlets [1] [2]. These removals represent the highest annual total since 2014 and show a sharp year-over-year rise from roughly 142,580 the prior fiscal year, driven largely by increased removals to Mexico and countries in Central America [2]. Below is a multi-source, dated analysis that extracts key claims, compares reporting, and flags noteworthy omissions.
1. How the headline number was reported and where it came from
ICE’s official enforcement and removal statistics provide the primary quantitative basis for the 271,484 removals figure cited in late-December reports; news organizations referencing that ICE release published matching totals dated December 19–20, 2024 [1] [2]. Government releases and mainstream outlets uniformly describe fiscal 2024 as the highest removal tally since 2014, with Mexico the most common destination. Those same reports note that quarterly breakdowns were published earlier—such as a third-quarter FY2024 spike to nearly 68,000 removals—yet the full fiscal-year consolidation was delivered in the late-December ICE reporting cycle [3] [2]. The convergence of ICE data and independent reporting makes the 271k figure the best-supported public number for FY2024 [1] [4].
2. Who these removals covered and how sources described them
Reporting emphasizes that the removals encompassed noncitizens deported to 192 countries, with Mexico, Guatemala, and Honduras repeatedly named as top destinations, and that a significant portion had prior criminal histories—figures reported as “over 30%” in some summaries [2] [5]. News coverage framed the removals as both border apprehension-driven and stemming from ICE interior enforcement, and mentioned stepped-up flight operations and expedited travel arrangements as operational enablers. Different outlets emphasize different aspects: some foreground the absolute count and historic comparison, others highlight composition (criminal vs. non-criminal, country of origin) and operational changes that facilitated higher removal rates [1] [5].
3. Year-over-year change and historical context journalists emphasized
Multiple sources calculate the 2024 removals as approximately a 90% increase from FY2023 totals—a jump from about 142,580 to 271,484—making 2024 the largest in a decade [2] [6]. Analysts and journalists compared the 2024 figures to Trump-era removal totals, noting 2024 outpaced removals during the 2017–2021 Trump administration according to the cited reporting. Historical framing is used to signal a policy and operational shift, but reporting does not uniformly ascribe the increase to a single cause; outlets list several contributors, including more border apprehensions, operational prioritization, and logistical changes that speeded returns [1] [4].
4. What the agency reports did not fully disclose and what reporters flagged
ICE’s public summaries and ensuing coverage provide totals but leave gaps on legal status nuances—reports do not fully enumerate how many removed were lawful permanent residents, green card holders, long-term lawful residents, or noncitizens with pending relief claims. Journalists noted that ICE’s aggregated totals do not breakdown removals by immigration status categories in a manner that answers the specific question “How many legal immigrants were deported?” Consequently, while the fiscal-year total of ~271,000 removals is solid, the portion that were legal permanent residents or otherwise lawfully present is not specified in the public summaries cited [3] [2].
5. Competing narratives and possible agendas in coverage
Coverage varies by outlet and emphasizes different frames: some present the figure as evidence of restored enforcement and border control efficacy, while others highlight humanitarian or due-process concerns about expedited removals and the potential targeting of vulnerable or legally present groups. These frames reflect political and editorial agendas; pro-enforcement narratives prioritize aggregate deterrent effects and historical comparisons, whereas critical accounts stress individual legal status and procedural safeguards that aggregate data do not reveal [1] [2] [6].
6. What additional data is needed to answer the original question precisely
To answer “How many legal immigrants were deported by ICE in 2024?” with precision, ICE or DHS would need to publish a disaggregated removal dataset that breaks out removals by lawful permanent resident status, visa holders, people with pending asylum or relief claims, and other categories. None of the December 2024 summaries cited in these reports provide that granularity; they offer total removals, country destinations, and some criminal-history percentages, but not a clear count of removals of legal permanent residents or other lawful-status immigrants [3] [5].
7. Bottom line and best-supported public answer right now
The best-supported public figure is that ICE removed about 271,484 noncitizens in fiscal year 2024, the highest annual total since 2014; however, public ICE reports and contemporaneous news coverage do not specify how many of those removed were legal immigrants (e.g., lawful permanent residents). Without ICE/DHS publishing a disaggregated status breakdown, the specific count of “legal immigrants deported in 2024” remains unavailable in the public record cited here [1] [2].