Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Fact check: How many deportations were conducted by ICE in 2024 for comparison?
Executive Summary
ICE reported 271,484 deportations in fiscal year 2024, a figure agencies and outlets described as a decade high and higher than the 2019 Trump-era peak; multiple government and media summaries place the removals to 192 countries and note a substantial rise from roughly 142,580 the prior year [1] [2] [3]. The data show that the 2024 total both surpassed recent prior peaks and reflected a sharp year-over-year increase, while reporting also highlighted that a significant share of those removed had criminal histories and that many removals followed border apprehensions [1] [4] [5].
1. Why the 2024 number reads like a headline: Context behind the 271,484 figure
The 271,484 count comes from ICE’s FY2024 tally and was widely reported as a 10-year high; outlets emphasized that this number exceeded the prior peak of about 267,000 in 2019, making 2024 the highest total since 2014 [5]. The agency’s report frames these removals as “noncitizens with final orders of removal,” a category that excludes administrative returns or other informal departures and thus reflects formal removals under immigration law [1]. That distinction helps explain why some year-to-year comparisons can vary depending on whether analysts include CBP expulsions, ICE administrative removals, or only formal deportations.
2. How sharp was the year-over-year rise and what drives it? A look at the numbers
ICE’s FY2024 total of 271,484 represents nearly a doubling from the roughly 142,580 removals reported for the prior 12-month period, signaling a rapid operational shift [2]. Reporters and the ICE summary attribute much of the increase to heightened enforcement, processing capacity, and the return of migration flows that created more removal cases with final orders; the scale and speed of the rise are notable because they reversed several years of lower removals. The data imply that policies, resource allocation, and enforcement priorities in 2024 combined to produce a substantially larger pool of enforced removals than in 2023.
3. Who was deported? Criminal histories and the makeup of removals
ICE’s own reporting states over 30% of those removed had criminal histories, with the agency noting an average of 5.63 convictions or charges per individual removed in FY2024 [1]. Media reports highlighted that removals involved migrants from 192 countries, indicating broad geographic reach [1] [3]. Other coverage emphasized that many deportations stemmed from migrants apprehended at the border, with one outlet reporting 82% of removals originated from Customs and Border Protection apprehensions, which underscores the role of border processing and interagency handoffs in producing removal numbers [4].
4. Comparing to prior peaks: Is 2024 truly the high-water mark?
Multiple sources align in describing FY2024 as the highest ICE deportation tally since 2014 and note it surpassed the 2019 Trump-era peak of about 267,000 removals [5] [2]. The convergence of independent media summaries and the ICE annual report supports the conclusion that 2024’s tally is a modern high. However, comparisons across years depend on whether analysts count only ICE removals with final orders or broader categories—some historical tallies include different administrative practices—so the claim of a “decade high” rests on the consistent use of ICE’s formal-removal metric.
5. What reporters and the agency emphasize — and what they don’t
Coverage and ICE’s summary both emphasize aggregate counts, criminal-justice metrics, and country destinations as indicators of enforcement focus [1] [3]. They are less detailed about the breakdown of removals by individual case types (e.g., asylum denials, expedited removals) and the time lags between final orders and physical removal. These omissions matter because they affect policy interpretation: a high total can reflect many cases resolved through faster administrative processes or backlog reductions rather than exclusively novel enforcement actions.
6. Possible agendas shaping coverage: How to read emphases and omissions
Different outlets frame the same ICE report through varied lenses: some stress the rise as a measure of restored enforcement capacity, while others highlight humanitarian or legal concerns about mass removals and border processing [5]. The government report’s focus on criminal convictions serves an enforcement-oriented narrative, whereas other commentators might prioritize the proportion of removals tied to border encounters. Recognizing these framing choices helps readers evaluate whether emphasis on crime, volume, or process best explains the significance of the 271,484 figure.
7. Bottom line for comparison questions and what to watch next
For direct comparison, use the ICE FY2024 total of 271,484 removals as the standard figure—this is the number most outlets and ICE provided and is explicitly labeled as removals to 192 countries [1] [3]. Analysts should pair that headline with year-over-year context (a jump from ~142,580) and with disaggregated case categories to understand drivers; future scrutiny should target detailed breakdowns by removal mechanism, timing from final order to removal, and country-level repatriation patterns to fully interpret enforcement trends in 2024 [2] [4].