Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Is trump a criminal?
Executive summary
Donald Trump has faced multiple criminal indictments across state and federal jurisdictions and was convicted in one New York case on 34 counts of falsifying business records in May 2024; that conviction was upheld by the trial judge but resulted in an unconditional discharge at sentencing on January 10, 2025 [1] [2]. Two federal prosecutions were paused or dismissed after his 2024 election victory and related immunity or appointment rulings, while the Georgia election-interference case remains active and was reassigned to a new prosecutor in late 2025 [3] [4] [5] [6].
1. The simple legal fact: indictments, convictions, dismissals
Donald Trump has been criminally charged in multiple matters: a New York state prosecution over hush-money payments that produced a 34-count conviction in May 2024, and several federal and state indictments related to classified documents and the 2020 election; some federal cases were later paused or dismissed after legal rulings and his 2024 election win [1] [2] [3] [4].
2. What “convicted” means here — the New York case’s outcome
In Manhattan, a jury found Trump guilty on all 34 counts tied to falsifying business records concerning payments to Stormy Daniels; Judge Juan Merchan upheld the conviction and later imposed an unconditional discharge on January 10, 2025 — meaning the conviction stands but produced no jail, fine, or probation in that sentencing [2] [7] [8].
3. Federal cases: immunity, appointments and procedural moves
Two federal prosecutions — the classified documents case and the election-certification case brought by Special Counsel Jack Smith — were affected by litigation over presidential immunity and appointment questions. After a Supreme Court ruling on immunity, and following Trump’s 2024 victory, Smith moved to dismiss the election case without prejudice; federal appeals and appointment disputes also led to dismissals or pauses in the documents case [3] [9] [4].
4. Georgia: the last active criminal prosecution and prosecutorial complications
Fulton County’s racketeering-style election-interference indictment has been the last principal state criminal matter still pending; District Attorney Fani Willis was disqualified by state courts over a conflict-of-interest appearance, and in November 2025 Pete Skandalakis was appointed to review and proceed with the prosecution [6] [5].
5. Legal status versus the political question “Is he a criminal?”
Whether someone is “a criminal” has two distinct meanings: legally, it refers to having been convicted of a crime; politically or colloquially, it can mean accused of wrongdoing. Legally, Trump has a recorded conviction in the New York case (May 30, 2024) that remains on the record despite the January 2025 unconditional discharge [2]. Other cases have produced indictments, dismissals, or are ongoing, so broad labels that ignore differing outcomes and procedural contexts oversimplify complex, divergent legal results [1] [3] [4].
6. Competing narratives in coverage and the role of procedure
Supporters often point to dismissals, immunity rulings, and the unconditional discharge as evidence that prosecutions were political or procedurally defective; prosecutors and some legal observers stress that the government “stands fully behind” the merits of at least some of the federal prosecutions and that dismissals were driven by immunity or appointment disputes rather than the absence of evidence [9] [4]. The records show both: a criminal conviction on state charges and serious unresolved or paused federal/state matters shaped by legal technicalities and prosecutorial decisions [2] [3] [9].
7. What reporting does not settle — limitations and open questions
Available sources do not mention a final, nationwide legal determination that resolves every allegation against Trump across all jurisdictions; several cases were dismissed without prejudice (allowing potential re-filing), some were paused by immunity rulings, and one significant state case remains in active transition to a new prosecutor [9] [3] [5]. The long-term legal status could change if charges are refiled, appeals succeed, or courts revisit appointment/immunity issues [4] [3].
8. Bottom line for readers: law, record, and context
Factually: Trump has been convicted in at least one criminal case (New York falsifying business records, May 2024) and has faced multiple other indictments with mixed procedural outcomes; several matters were dismissed, paused, or reassigned after court rulings and his election [2] [3] [4]. Interpretations differ sharply along political lines, and the legal record is a patchwork of convictions, dismissals, and ongoing prosecutions rather than a single, unambiguous verdict about all accusations [1] [9] [6].