Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
What exactly did Kristi Noem say about 9 million Social Security numbers and in what speech or interview was it made?
Executive Summary
Kristi Noem has been attributed with statements claiming roughly 9 million Social Security numbers were issued to noncitizens or improperly processed during the Biden administration, but the documentary record in the assembled sources is mixed and inconclusive: one April 14, 2025 report records Noem making that claim on Fox & Friends and describing task‑force findings, while multiple other contemporaneous and earlier reports about Social Security number leaks, Jan. 6 document redactions, and federal program queries do not attribute a 9 million figure to Noem and instead discuss very different counts and programs [1] [2] [3] [4]. The net finding: the 9 million figure appears in at least one media account tied to a specific interview, but that claim lacks corroboration across the broader set of documents and may conflate different government data runs and program reports; further primary verification (video/transcript of the Fox & Friends segment or a direct Noem statement) is needed to confirm her exact words and the underlying data [1] [4].
1. Why the 9 million figure surfaced and who reported it like a bombshell
A news account dated April 14, 2025 quotes Gov. Noem saying about 9 million non‑U.S. citizens received Social Security numbers during the Biden administration and describes her remarks as coming in a Fox & Friends interview; the same account reports she cited a task force that identified thousands of problematic cases and urged cancellation of fraudulent numbers [1]. That report frames the 9 million number as an aggregate tally and connects it to enforcement actions already underway, presenting Noem’s claim as an operational update rather than a rhetorical flourish. Other contemporaneous materials, however, address different numeric episodes—leaks of about 2,000 Social Security numbers in Jan. 2020 guest logs and cancellation of thousands of numbers tied to specific enforcement sweeps—so readers should note the significant gap between two‑thousand‑level incidents and the nine‑million claim [2] [3] [5].
2. Deep dive: sources that document leaks, redactions and the Jan. 6 guest‑list episode
Multiple earlier reports document high‑profile disclosures of Social Security numbers tied to the Jan. 6 committee’s document release, where a White House guest log containing nearly 2,000 Social Security numbers was published unredacted and included Gov. Noem’s number among others; Noem demanded investigations and alleged Privacy Act violations in those instances [2] [3] [6]. These stories establish documented harms, media attention, and official complaints, but they do not substantiate a broader claim that millions of Social Security numbers were improperly issued. The Jan. 6 leak remains a discrete, verifiable episode and is not numerically compatible with the assertion of nine million improperly issued numbers without additional explanation or supporting data [2] [3].
3. Alternative explanations: different programs, different 9‑million tallies
A separate thread in the corpus involves federal programs and data runs that have numbers in the millions—such as the Department of Homeland Security’s use of verification systems running millions of records through SAVE or other databases—where a 9 million figure appears in a congressional letter or program description rather than as a claim about Social Security numbers specifically [4]. This suggests a plausible source of conflation: a 9 million count tied to voter‑record checks or SAVE queries can be miscast as Social Security number issuance. The documents show clear instances where millions of records were processed for non‑SSN purposes, meaning the 9 million figure may reference a different dataset or verification run, not issuance of Social Security numbers to noncitizens [4].
4. Contradictions and gaps: where the record does not support a straightforward claim
Several reviews and fact checks in the set explicitly find no mention of a 9 million Social Security number claim in their articles and flag smaller, documented figures instead—thousands of leaked numbers or targeted cancellations in enforcement actions—undermining a simple acceptance of the nine‑million claim without primary sourcing [2] [3] [5]. The lone direct attribution [1] therefore stands at odds with a body of reporting that documents different phenomena and numbers; absent a primary video clip or transcript of the alleged Fox & Friends exchange, the scale and context of Noem’s remark remain insufficiently corroborated across the available documents.
5. Bottom line and next steps for verification
The most defensible conclusion from these sources is that Gov. Noem was reported to have said a 9 million figure in an April 14, 2025 media account tied to Fox & Friends, but that other reports and official documents cite very different counts and programs—creating a credible risk of conflation between Social Security number issuance and large data‑processing runs by federal systems [1] [4] [2]. To confirm precisely what Noem said and in what context, the optimal next step is to obtain the primary source: the Fox & Friends transcript or video from April 2025 or a direct press release from Noem’s office; until that primary evidence is produced, treating the 9 million claim as unverified and potentially conflated with other federal data tallies is warranted [1] [4].