Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Fact check: How do the number of Muslim mayors in English cities in 2025 compare to previous years?
Executive summary
The sources provided offer conflicting claims about how many Muslim mayors served in English cities in 2025: one set reports a notable increase with four Muslim women holding mayoral roles in 2025, while another set identifies only one confirmed Muslim mayor in England—Sadiq Khan, Mayor of London—still in office in 2025 [1] [2] [3]. The dispute hinges on differences in definition, scope and reporting in the available materials, and the evidence in these documents does not converge to a single, fully substantiated count [1] [2] [4].
1. Why the headlines diverge: competing source narratives that clash
The most striking divergence appears between a 2025 profile that highlights four Muslim women serving as mayors—Sherin Akthar, Safiya Saeed, Rukhsana Ismail and Munazza Faiz—and a set of encyclopedic and news pieces that treat Sadiq Khan as the lone Muslim mayor in English cities as of 2025 [1] [2] [4]. The first narrative frames 2025 as a historic milestone for Muslim women’s representation, while the second situates continuity: Khan’s 2016 breakthrough raised the count from zero to one, and by 2025 London remains the only documented English city with a Muslim directly elected mayor in these sources [1] [3].
2. What each source actually says and the dates that matter
The profile listing four Muslim women as mayors is dated June 20, 2025 and presents a contemporary snapshot asserting a notable increase in representation [1]. The complementary demographic pieces from early and spring 2025 report growth in the Muslim population and census complexity, which are offered as a broader context that could explain rising political representation [5] [6]. By contrast, the Wikipedia and Mayor of London pages and related coverage documenting Sadiq Khan’s 2016, 2021 and 2024 wins were accessed or dated in late September 2025 and emphasize Khan’s unique status as a Muslim mayor in England [2] [3] [4].
3. Definitions matter: mayoral office types and how that changes counts
The materials do not consistently define what counts as a “mayor”—directly elected metro mayors, ceremonial council mayors, and mayors of smaller towns or combined authorities can all be described as mayors in popular reporting. The June 2025 profile that lists four Muslim women does not, in the excerpts provided, clarify whether those are directly elected executive mayors, ceremonial mayors, or local council mayors, while the September 2025 sources explicitly treat Sadiq Khan as the capital’s directly elected Mayor of London, a prominent executive post [1] [2] [3]. This definitional gap is central to the conflicting counts.
4. Cross‑checking context: demographics and political mobilisation
Several sources argue that demographic change underpins rising representation: the Muslim Council of Britain’s reporting and a census summary in 2025 note an expanding Muslim population and a younger profile, which can translate into greater electoral influence and more officeholders over time [5] [6]. These contextual data points support the plausibility of increased local representation in 2025 but do not, by themselves, verify the specific number of Muslim mayors across English cities without clear office definitions and comprehensive local election returns [5] [6].
5. Reliability, possible agendas and what’s missing from the record
The June 2025 profile foregrounding four Muslim women mayors promotes a narrative of representation and women’s empowerment, which can signal an advocacy or celebratory angle in coverage; the September 2025 encyclopedic and international outlets underscore Sadiq Khan’s historical singularity, reflecting emphasis on high‑profile executive offices [1] [2] [4]. The record lacks a systematic, dated roster of mayoral offices across English local authorities in 2025, and none of the provided excerpts reconcile the different lists or specify the mayoral types they count [1] [3].
6. Bottom line and what to verify next to resolve the discrepancy
Based on the documents at hand, two defensible statements emerge: first, Sadiq Khan was a Muslim mayor of London through 2025 and remains a clear, documented case [2] [3]. Second, at least one 2025 profile claims that four Muslim women held mayoral roles that year, a claim supported by demographic context but not corroborated by the mayoral‑office‑specific sources provided [1] [5]. To resolve the discrepancy conclusively, one must obtain a dated, office‑by‑office list specifying whether each counted mayor is an executive, ceremonial or parish mayor and cross‑check local election records for 2025.