Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Fact check: How does the number of party switches since 2020 compare to previous election cycles?
Executive Summary
Since 2020 the available analyses indicate a modest but measurable uptick in elected officials switching parties, driven largely by state legislators moving from Democrat to Republican; 2024 registered a notable count of more than five party switchers for Republicans — the first comparable level since 2011 — signaling a higher tempo than the immediate pre‑2020 cycles [1] [2]. Long‑term data show the phenomenon is not new: over 400 state legislators switched between 1989 and 2020, overwhelmingly toward the GOP, but the post‑2020 years appear to have produced a greater short‑term concentration of switches than the 2016–2019 period [2] [3].
1. A resurgence or blip? What the numbers since 2020 actually say
The assembled sources do not provide a single, definitive national total of party switches since 2020, but they converge on a pattern: more switches toward Republicans and an uptick in 2023–2024. Ballotpedia’s 2023 count found 10 state lawmakers switching in 2023, roughly double the 30‑year annual average, and noted Republicans gained more seats through switches in most years since 1994 [3]. Coverage in early 2025 reported that Republicans claimed more than five party switchers in 2024 — the first time since 2011 — and cited two Florida House flips after the 2024 election, signaling concentrated activity rather than a nationwide mass defection [1].
2. Historical baseline: decades of asymmetry favoring one party
Longer historical reporting establishes that party switching is a recurring but uneven phenomenon. An April 2023 review documented over 400 state legislative switches from 1989 to 2020, “overwhelmingly from Democrat to Republican,” creating a long‑run asymmetry that frames post‑2020 movement as continuation rather than a new reversal [2]. Sources emphasize that, while switches spike in particular years — notably 2011 and recently 2023–2024 — the baseline across multiple decades has leaned toward Republican gains via switching, so comparisons should account for that persistent directional trend [3] [2].
3. Geographic and institutional concentration: where switches matter most
Available reporting highlights state legislatures and suburban areas as the main sites of switching. Ballotpedia’s series and other analyses show state legislative switches have been the dominant venue for party change, and the Associated Press reported voter registration flips concentrated in suburbs, with about two‑thirds moving to the GOP in a 2022 snapshot [3] [4]. The post‑2020 uptick appears especially relevant in Southern legislatures and competitive suburban districts, where individual flips can affect supermajorities or chamber control, more so than isolated federal‑level changes [2] [4].
4. Interpreting the 2023–2024 increase: trend or cyclical noise?
Analysts differ on whether the 2023–2024 rise is a durable realignment or a short‑term response to local factors. Reporting in 2023 and early 2025 frames the increase as statistically above recent averages — 2023’s switches were roughly twice the 30‑year annual average, and 2024 saw the highest Republican tally since 2011 — but both accounts also stress local drivers like ideological fit, intra‑party conflict, and state politics rather than a single national cause [3] [1]. This nuance matters: a handful of strategic flips in key states can have outsized effects without signaling wholesale party collapse or mass migration.
5. Data gaps and methodological caveats you should know
The sources supplied do not offer a unified, up‑to‑date national ledger of party switches since 2020, and journalists rely on patchwork tracking across states. Ballotpedia compiles state legislative moves, while news outlets cite individual cases and registration data, but differences in definitions (registered voters versus elected officials), time windows, and reporting thresholds complicate comparisons across cycles [2] [4]. Any cross‑cycle comparison must account for these methodological variances and for year‑to‑year concentration: a single year with several strategic flips will look large compared with many years of scattered changes.
6. What the multiple perspectives suggest about future cycles
Taken together, the sources indicate that post‑2020 party switching shows a heightened short‑term frequency with continued Republican advantage, but not a mass realignment comparable to historical party system transformations. The 2023–2024 activity resembles earlier concentrated surges (e.g., 2011) superimposed on a longer trend of GOP gains via switching, implying policymakers, parties, and analysts should watch state legislatures and suburban registration patterns for further signals rather than treating the recent years as definitive proof of a new national equilibrium [1] [2].
Conclusion: If you need a precise national count since 2020, current sources in this dossier are insufficient for an exact tally; they do, however, consistently show a modest post‑2020 rise in switching—principally toward Republicans and concentrated in state legislatures and suburbs—relative to the immediately preceding cycles [3] [1].