Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Fact check: Of the 3,112 counties, did Republicans win a larger share of the vote in 2024 compared to 2020?
Executive Summary
The preponderance of contemporary analyses indicates Republicans increased their vote share in most U.S. counties in 2024 compared with 2020, with multiple outlets describing a broad “red shift” and noting Trump gained ground in the majority of counties and states [1] [2] [3]. These accounts converge on a national pattern: a widespread county-level swing toward Republicans, though they also stress the shift was uneven across states, counties, and demographic groups [3] [4]. Below I extract the central claims, weigh corroborating and qualifying evidence, and flag important omissions and alternative interpretations.
1. What advocates of the claim point to — a national red tide that’s hard to ignore
Multiple national news analyses assert that Trump and Republicans improved their county-level performance in 2024 relative to 2020, with some outlets quantifying the breadth of the shift: ABC reported that 92% of voters lived in counties that swung toward Trump, and NPR described wins in suburbs and amplified margins in rural areas [1] [2]. CNN and other outlets highlighted unexpected county swings and large numbers of counties moving toward Republicans, using county-by-county comparisons to support the claim that Republicans won a larger share of the vote across most of the national map [5].
2. State-level snapshots that bolster the national picture
State reports provide concrete examples consistent with the national narrative: Michigan’s official post‑election review noted that 75 of 83 counties shifted Republican and that Trump increased his vote share in almost every county compared with 2020, which mirrors the pattern claimed at the national level [6]. Pennsylvania’s voter-registration changes showing Republican and independent gains were offered as supporting evidence for a Republican advantage in turnout or share, though that data is indirect and doesn’t by itself demonstrate county-level vote swings [7]. These state vignettes strengthen the case but leave room for local variation.
3. Independent analysis and nuance — the shift is broad but not uniform
Academic and analytical pieces warn that the swing was not homogeneous: The Conversation and other analysts emphasize that while many counties swung right, the magnitude varied considerably by region and demographic composition, and some counties or metropolitan areas moved differently [3] [4]. This caveat matters because headline statements about “most counties” can mask important pockets where Democrats held or improved support, which influences how the raw county counts translate into electoral outcomes and policy implications.
4. Demographics and coalitions help explain where Republicans gained
Research on changing partisan coalitions identified preexisting trends—Republican inroads among voters without a college degree, shifts among some Hispanic voters, and white evangelical consolidation—that likely amplified Republican county gains in 2024 [4] [8]. Pew’s demographic analyses provide context showing structural shifts in voter identification that would predispose certain counties to swing right, though those studies do not directly measure the 2024 county vote comparisons; they do, however, offer a plausible mechanism for the observed electoral shifts [8].
5. Conflicting signals and limits of the available evidence
Not all of the sourced material is purely quantitative: some reports use voter-registration trends or selective state examples as proxies, which do not substitute for comprehensive county-by-county vote tabulations [7]. The summary claims rely on aggregated media analyses that may emphasize breadth over depth, and while multiple outlets independently reported similar patterns, the absence of a single, fully cited national county-by-county dataset within these analyses means the conclusion rests on convergent journalistic and state-level reports rather than a single unanimity of official national metric [1] [5].
6. Potential agendas to watch in the coverage
Coverage from partisan-leaning or advocacy-oriented outlets can frame county swings in politically consequential ways: some narratives highlight a tectonic realignment to bolster claims of a durable Republican advantage, while others temper conclusions to preserve Democratic optimism about urban and suburban resilience [3] [4]. The sources supplied are mainstream news and research outlets; readers should note that emphasis and framing differ—some foreground breadth (number of counties), others emphasize margins or demographic drivers—which can shape perceptions of how decisive the 2024 county-level shift truly was.
7. Bottom line and recommended next steps for verification
Based on the supplied analyses, the best current summary is that Republicans did increase their share of the vote in a majority of U.S. counties in 2024 relative to 2020, supported by multiple independent media reports and state examples [1] [2] [6] [5]. For definitive confirmation, consult a complete, dated county-level vote dataset (e.g., official state canvasses aggregated by a nonpartisan data repository) to compute the exact count of counties where Republican share rose versus fell; the sources here strongly suggest the trend but stop short of providing a single exhaustive county tally [1].