How many states have redistricted prior to a census prior to 2020
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Was this fact-check helpful?
1. Summary of the results
Based on the analyses provided, there is limited specific information available to directly answer the question about how many states redistricted prior to a census before 2020. The sources primarily focus on the 2020 redistricting cycle and its aftermath rather than historical pre-census redistricting patterns.
The most relevant finding comes from one source which indicates that Texas redistricted in 2003, demonstrating that at least one state has engaged in mid-decade redistricting prior to 2020 [1]. This source notes that while it's "unusual, but not unprecedented, to redraw those maps in the middle of the decade," it does not provide a comprehensive count of states that have done so.
The analyses reveal that redistricting typically occurs once every 10 years following the census [2], which is the standard constitutional practice. However, the sources indicate that mid-decade redistricting has occurred, with Texas serving as a documented example from 2003.
2. Missing context/alternative viewpoints
The original question lacks several important contextual elements that would provide a more complete understanding:
- Historical precedent and frequency: While Texas's 2003 redistricting is mentioned [1], there is no comprehensive historical analysis of how many other states have engaged in similar practices across different decades.
- Legal framework: The analyses reference significant Supreme Court cases like Baker v. Carr, Reynolds v. Sims, Thornburg v. Gingles, and Shaw v. Reno [3], which established crucial redistricting principles, but don't connect these to pre-census redistricting practices.
- Current political dynamics: The sources reveal that Trump is currently pressuring Republicans in Texas to redistrict again and is engaged in similar discussions in other GOP-controlled states including Missouri and Indiana [2] [4]. This suggests that mid-decade redistricting remains a contemporary political strategy.
- Litigation patterns: One analysis shows that 111 lawsuits were filed challenging maps drawn with 2020 census data, with two-thirds of all states seeing litigation over their maps [5], indicating the contentious nature of redistricting processes.
3. Potential misinformation/bias in the original statement
The original question itself does not contain explicit misinformation, but it may reflect certain assumptions or gaps:
- Incomplete scope: The question focuses specifically on pre-2020 activity but doesn't acknowledge that mid-decade redistricting continues to be a relevant political issue, as evidenced by current Republican efforts in multiple states [2].
- Missing political context: The question doesn't address the partisan motivations behind mid-decade redistricting. The sources indicate that such efforts are often driven by political parties seeking to "pick up more seats in the U.S. House" [4], suggesting that redistricting outside the normal census cycle is typically a strategic political maneuver rather than a routine administrative process.
- Lack of legal distinction: The question doesn't differentiate between legally mandated redistricting (following census data) and politically motivated redistricting, which represents a significant conceptual gap in understanding the practice.
The analyses suggest that while the practice exists, comprehensive data on the exact number of states that have redistricted prior to a census before 2020 is not readily available in the sources provided.