Have independent sources or medical experts commented on the accuracy of Trump's 2024/2025 height and weight listing?

1. What was released and who reported it

The official public record in this reporting cycle is the three‑page summary from White House physician Navy Capt. Sean Barbabella, which lists a height of 75 inches and a weight of 224 pounds and states the president is “fully fit to execute the duties of Commander‑in‑Chief,” and the memo was republished by multiple outlets, including TIME, AP and the American Presidency Project ^{[1] [2] [3]}. Newsrooms such as PBS, Stat and The Independent covered the same figures and noted the exam included diagnostic and specialist consultations as described by the physician ^{[4] [8] [5]}.

2. Did independent journalists or reporters independently confirm the measurements?

The coverage examined shows mainstream outlets relaying the physician’s summary rather than conducting independent physical re‑measurements or obtaining corroborating medical data from an outside clinician; reporting focused on publishing and interpreting the memo rather than describing an independent verification process ^{[1] [2] [8]}. The public disclosures were made with the president’s consent and centralized in the White House physician’s memo, and none of the sourced articles cite an independent hospital measurement or an external clinician who re‑took height or weight outside the Walter Reed exam ^{[3] [4]}.

3. Have medical experts publicly vouched for or challenged the accuracy?

Direct commentary from impartial, named medical experts explicitly verifying or disputing the recorded 75‑inch/224‑pound figures is not present in the sample of reporting reviewed; instead, medical discussion in the coverage leans toward interpretation — for example, several outlets pointed out the BMI derived from those numbers places Trump in the “overweight” category and noted broader critiques of BMI as an imperfect measure of health, citing authorities like Yale Medicine ^{[4] [5]}. The reporting does not include an independent clinician saying “these numbers are correct” or “these numbers are false”; it records the physician’s assessment and physician‑supervised testing but not third‑party remeasurement ^{[4] [3]}.

4. Skepticism, history and context that shape reactions

Skepticism in the public sphere about presidential medical disclosures is longstanding and informed reactions to the 2025 memo; outlets noted past episodes in which Trump’s reported weights drew disbelief on social media and in commentary, and reporting flagged that Trump had not released comprehensive historical records during the 2024 campaign, a transparency issue critics cite when questioning any single memo (The Independent; Axios; Wikipedia) ^{[5] [6] [7]}. The reporting also highlights that while the White House released details from Walter Reed, the institution and physician have an implicit interest in framing the president as fit, a reality that readers are advised to weigh alongside the absence of independent remeasurement cited in the coverage ^{[3] [2]}.

5. Bottom line — direct answer to the question

Based on the sources provided, independent outlets widely reported the height and weight as recorded by the White House physician, but there is no documented independent remeasurement or named external medical expert in these articles who verified or refuted the 75‑inch/224‑pound listing; commentary from medical sources in the coverage focuses on interpretation of those numbers (BMI limitations, fitness conclusions) and historical skepticism rather than on direct validation of the measurements themselves ^{[1] [4] [5] [6] [3]}.