What did Trump say about criticizing the president being illegal?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Was this fact-check helpful?
1. Summary of the results
The original statement asks about Donald Trump's comments on criticizing the president being illegal. According to [1], Trump criticized US media coverage, calling it 'illegal' and claiming that networks report '97 per cent bad' news about him [1]. However, this statement seems to be more about Trump's perception of media coverage rather than a direct claim that criticizing the president is illegal. [2] highlights the ACLU's argument that the Trump administration is abusing its power to intimidate critics, which could be related to the claim, but does not directly quote Trump saying criticizing the president is illegal [2]. [3] reports that Trump said his negative media coverage is 'illegal' and that he thinks the FCC should investigate broadcasters who air negative coverage of him [3].
Further analyses from [2], [4], and [5] suggest that while Trump has made statements about TV networks 'against' him possibly losing their license, and has pressured media outlets, he does not explicitly state that criticizing the president is illegal [2] [4] [5]. [6] describes Trump's actions against media outlets as a pattern of behavior intended to silence dissent, but does not directly quote Trump on the issue [6]. [7] discusses Trump's lawsuit against The New York Times as part of a pattern of 'weaponized litigation' to punish publishers, but does not address the issue of criticizing the president being illegal [7]. [8] is unrelated to the topic [8].
2. Missing context/alternative viewpoints
A key missing context in the original statement is the distinction between Trump's personal perception of media coverage and his actual statements on the legality of criticizing the president. The analyses provide alternative viewpoints from the ACLU, which argues that the Trump administration's actions are a threat to free speech [2], and from experts who consider Trump's lawsuits against media outlets as meritless and part of a pattern of 'weaponized litigation' [7]. Additionally, the fact that Trump has pressured media outlets and individuals who criticize him suggests a pattern of behavior intended to silence dissent [4] [6].
Some specific facts or context that are missing in the user's query include:
- The exact quotes from Trump's statements on media coverage and criticizing the president
- The legal basis for Trump's claims that negative media coverage is 'illegal'
- The response from media outlets and individuals who have been targeted by Trump's actions
- The potential consequences of Trump's actions on free speech and the media landscape
3. Potential misinformation/bias in the original statement
The original statement may contain potential misinformation as it asks about Trump's comments on criticizing the president being illegal, but the analyses suggest that Trump's statements are more about his perception of media coverage and his actions to intimidate critics rather than a direct claim that criticizing the president is illegal [1] [3]. The statement may also reflect a bias in presenting Trump's views on media coverage as a claim about the legality of criticizing the president, rather than a personal opinion or an attempt to silence dissent.
The beneficiaries of this framing include:
- Trump and his administration, who may use this narrative to justify their actions against media outlets and critics
- Media outlets and individuals who may use this narrative to criticize Trump's actions and defend free speech
- The ACLU and other organizations that argue that the Trump administration's actions are a threat to free speech and democracy [2]