Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Fact check: What were the deportation numbers during Trump's first term?
Executive Summary
The question asks for deportation numbers during President Trump’s first term (January 2017–January 2021); available, vetted analyses show interior removals rose compared with the immediately preceding year but did not exceed historical peaks from 2008–2012, and fiscal-year ICE data records 226,119 removals in FY2017 with 81,603 stemming from ICE arrests [1] [2]. Claims from later reporting that millions were removed or self-deported under a later Trump administration (2025 reports) are separate, post-2021 claims and do not describe the 2017–2021 period [3] [4] [5].
1. Why the headline FY2017 number matters — and what it actually records
The Department of Homeland Security’s FY2017 Enforcement and Removal Operations report documents 226,119 total ICE removals in fiscal year 2017, and of those, 81,603 resulted from ICE arrests, a 36% increase from FY2016; the report ties shifts to Executive Order 13768, which reprioritized enforcement [1]. This FY2017 figure covers the first full fiscal year after the administration took office and captures a policy-driven change in arrest and removal focus, but it is a single-year snapshot; readers should not conflate fiscal-year tallies with total “administration-era” cumulative removals or with other DHS metrics that separate border encounters, expulsions, or self-deportations [1] [2].
2. Interior removals rose but stayed below prior-era peaks — the longer historical arc
Analyses placing Trump-era interior removals in context note that while interior removals increased relative to the immediately preceding years, they remained lower than removal levels recorded between 2008 and 2012, and interior deportations during the Trump first term never exceeded 100,000 per year according to the compiled analyses [2]. This contextualizes the FY2017 spike: the administration shifted enforcement priorities to interior arrests and community-based actions — including a rise in arrests of non-criminals in communities from 3,970 in FY2016 to 10,245 in FY2019 — but those changes did not by themselves recreate earlier, larger-scale removal volumes from the late 2000s and early 2010s [2].
3. Claims of “millions” removed or self-deported in later Trump-era reporting — separate timeframe and different metrics
Recent [6] reports allege that “over 2 million illegal aliens” left the country within months under a later Trump administration, splitting that total into about 1.6 million self-deportations and roughly 400,000 formal deportations, and presenting that period as an unprecedented surge [3] [4] [5]. Those 2025 DHS-reported figures reflect a distinct period and operational context after 2021, and cannot be retroactively applied to Trump’s 2017–2021 first term. Treat these later claims as post-2021 outcomes that use different counting approaches (self-deportation vs. formal removals) and are not evidence about FY2017–FY2020 removal totals [3] [5].
4. Discrepancies between metrics — removals, removals from ICE arrests, expulsions, and self-deportations
What counts as a “deportation” varies across sources: ICE’s Enforcement and Removal Operations tracks removals and distinguishes removals resulting from ICE arrests; other DHS statements and media reports use broader language including self-deportations or summary tallies that combine expulsions, transfers, and voluntary departures [1] [3]. Because these categories measure different processes and actors — border expulsions under Title 42, formal ICE removals, or voluntary departures/self-deportations — aggregation without clear definitions produces confusion; the FY2017 ICE report is valuable because it specifies those subcategories, whereas some later 2025 reporting aggregates disparate categories into a single headline figure [1] [5].
5. How enforcement priorities changed and what that means for raw numbers
Executive actions in early 2017 shifted DHS and ICE priorities toward broader interior enforcement, which raised community arrests and the share of removals initiated by ICE rather than by prior immigration enforcement patterns [1] [2]. That change explains increases in certain categories (ICE-initiated removals, community arrests) even as total annual interior removals stayed below earlier historical highs. Policymakers and analysts must therefore interpret the numbers as policy-driven redistributions of enforcement effort, not solely as a simple increase or decrease in overall removals without context [1] [2].
6. Bottom line for someone asking “What were deportation numbers during Trump’s first term?”
The best-established, contemporaneous data point is 226,119 ICE removals in FY2017, with 81,603 from ICE arrests, and analyses show that interior removals increased compared with 2016 but did not surpass the larger removal levels seen in 2008–2012, nor did interior removals exceed 100,000 annually across the Trump first term [1] [2]. Separate 2025 reports of millions leaving the United States describe a later period with different definitions and should not be used to characterize 2017–2021 removal totals without careful disaggregation [3] [5].