Keep Factually independent

Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.

Loading...Time left: ...
Loading...Goal: $500

Fact check: Was trump actually on TV talking about "selling" immigrants to farms, i.e., slavery?

Checked on July 5, 2025

1. Summary of the results

Based on the comprehensive analysis of multiple sources, there is no evidence that Trump was on television talking about "selling" immigrants to farms in the context of slavery. All sources consistently report on Trump's immigration policies related to migrant farm workers, but none support the specific claim about "selling" immigrants.

The sources reveal that Trump has discussed:

  • Developing a temporary pass system for immigrants working in certain industries, including farming, to address concerns about ICE arrests affecting farmers [1]
  • Willingness to let migrant laborers stay in the US if farmers vouch for them [2]
  • Efforts to balance immigration enforcement with the needs of industries that rely on migrant workers [3]

While Trump has made controversial statements about slavery in other contexts, such as downplaying the legacy of slavery and calling for "patriotic education" [4] and condemning American slavery at the 400th anniversary of Virginia's first legislative assembly [5], none of these relate to "selling" immigrants to farms.

2. Missing context/alternative viewpoints

The original question lacks important context about Trump's actual immigration policies regarding farm workers. The sources reveal that:

  • Agricultural industry stakeholders would benefit from Trump's proposed temporary pass system, as it would help address labor shortages while maintaining immigration enforcement [1] [2]
  • Civil liberties organizations like the ACLU view Trump's immigration agenda as extreme, accusing him of seeking to "terrorize immigrant communities and violate their civil liberties" [6]
  • The broader immigration debate involves balancing enforcement with economic needs, particularly in agriculture where migrant workers are essential

The question also omits the distinction between legal immigration programs (like temporary worker passes) and the historical practice of slavery, which are fundamentally different concepts.

3. Potential misinformation/bias in the original statement

The original question appears to contain significant misinformation by conflating Trump's immigration policies with slavery. This conflation:

  • Mischaracterizes legitimate policy discussions about temporary worker programs as discussions about slavery
  • Uses inflammatory language ("selling" immigrants) that is not supported by any of the analyzed sources
  • May be designed to create outrage rather than seek factual information about Trump's actual statements and policies

The framing suggests potential bias by presenting an unsubstantiated claim as if it were established fact, asking "was Trump actually on TV" rather than "did Trump ever discuss" this topic. This type of loaded question can spread false narratives and contribute to political misinformation, potentially benefiting those who seek to discredit Trump through exaggerated or fabricated claims rather than focusing on his actual documented statements and policies.

Want to dive deeper?
What was the context of Trump's comments on immigrant labor?
Did Trump ever propose a plan to use immigrant labor on farms?
How have fact-checkers addressed Trump's remarks on immigration and labor?
What are the current US laws and regulations regarding immigrant labor?
How have Trump's comments on immigration impacted his relationship with farm lobby groups?