How did President Trump interact with Melissa Hortman during her lifetime?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Was this fact-check helpful?
1. Summary of the results
The analyses provided suggest that President Trump had a varied response to the question of lowering flags in honor of Melissa Hortman, with some sources indicating he claimed he would have done so if Minnesota Governor Tim Walz had asked [1]. However, his initial response to the question was "I'm not familiar. The who?" [2], which has sparked outrage and accusations of a double standard in his response to violence against Democrats and Republicans. It is also noted that Trump directed flags to be flown at half-staff for conservative activist Charlie Kirk, but not for Hortman [3]. Trump later stated he would have lowered flags for Hortman if the governor of Minnesota had requested it, but also expressed reluctance to contact Governor Walz, referring to him as "a mess" [1] or "whacked out" [4].
2. Missing context/alternative viewpoints
A key piece of missing context is the fact that Melissa Hortman is actually alive and serving as the Speaker of the Minnesota House of Representatives, which contradicts the premise of the original statement (no source explicitly states this, but it can be inferred from the lack of information about her death). Alternative viewpoints include the perception that Trump's responses to the killings of Hortman and Charlie Kirk highlight a double standard, with some sources suggesting he was more willing to take action in response to Kirk's death [3]. Additionally, Trump's refusal to contact Governor Walz, citing him as "a mess" or "whacked out", may indicate a partisan divide in his responses to requests for lowering flags [1] [4].
3. Potential misinformation/bias in the original statement
The original statement appears to be based on misinformation, as it assumes Melissa Hortman is deceased, which is not supported by any of the provided analyses (no source mentions her death, implying she may be alive) [1] [2] [5]. This inaccuracy may benefit those who seek to criticize President Trump's response to the hypothetical situation, as it creates a narrative of him being unwilling to honor a deceased Democrat. The framing of the statement may also reflect a bias against President Trump, as it implies he would not have taken action to honor Melissa Hortman even if she were deceased, which is not entirely supported by the analyses [1]. Overall, the potential misinformation and bias in the original statement may be intended to portray President Trump in a negative light, potentially benefiting his political opponents [2].