It asserts that Trump pardoned members of the Proud Boys.
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
Donald Trump issued a sweeping clemency on January 20, 2025 that pardoned or commuted the sentences of roughly 1,500 people charged or convicted in the January 6, 2021 Capitol attack, and that action specifically included members and leaders of the Proud Boys — notably Enrique (Henry) “Enrique” Tarrio — whose full pardon and the commutations of others produced immediate releases from prison [1] [2] [3]. Reporting across major outlets confirms both the blanket nature of the clemency and that 14 members of the Proud Boys and Oath Keepers had sentences commuted, with Tarrio among those publicly thanked by Proud Boys leaders [1] [4] [2].
1. What the pardon order did and how it applied to Proud Boys defendants
On his first day in office, Trump signed a proclamation granting full pardons to most defendants and commuting the sentences of a subset of high-profile militant defendants, a move that encompassed nearly 1,500 people tied to the Capitol attack and specifically commuted or pardoned leaders and members of the Proud Boys and Oath Keepers [5] [2] [1]. Multiple outlets reported that the commutations covered 14 members of those two groups and that Trump described the defendants as “hostages,” framing the clemency as corrective action [2] [1].
2. Which Proud Boys figures were affected and their criminal findings
Among the most widely reported beneficiaries was former Proud Boys leader Enrique Tarrio, who had been serving a 22-year sentence after a seditious conspiracy conviction and was granted a full pardon, while other Proud Boys such as Dominic Pezzola and additional members had sentences commuted or were included in the broader pardons [6] [7] [5]. Stewart Rhodes of the Oath Keepers — though not a Proud Boy — also received commutation; media noted that some pardoned individuals had been convicted of violent assaults on police and seditious conspiracy [8] [3] [2].
3. Legal effect: what a pardon or commutation actually does
A presidential pardon can remove penalties and, in many cases, restore civil rights, while a commutation reduces or ends the sentence but does not erase convictions from a criminal record; reporting emphasized that some defendants received full pardons while others had sentences commuted to time served, which freed them though convictions may remain on the books [2] [5]. Major outlets explained that pardons do not necessarily expunge convictions and that the Justice Department and courts retain the record of prior prosecutions even if the president has extended clemency [2] [5].
4. Immediate reactions and political framing
News organizations documented polarized responses: supporters cheered the releases and Proud Boys figures publicly thanked Trump, while critics — including victims’ families, law-enforcement advocates, civil-society researchers and some legal scholars — warned that the pardons undermine accountability for political violence and could encourage future extremist mobilization [4] [9] [10]. Trump defended the action as justice for what he called jailed “hostages,” and publicly suggested the Proud Boys and Oath Keepers might “have a place” in politics, a statement that galvanized concern among those who view the groups as extremist [11] [2].
5. Broader implications and competing interpretations
Legal scholars and counterterrorism researchers quoted in reporting argued the clemency represents an unprecedented use of presidential power that risks politicizing the justice system and emboldening violent actors, while some political allies framed it as correcting prosecutorial overreach and restoring mercy for supporters; outlets like Stanford Law and long-form coverage laid out both the constitutional scope and the normative alarm about future political violence [10] [7]. Media investigations into Proud Boys history and FBI characterizations were cited to underline why many see the pardons as consequential beyond individual cases [12] [6].
6. Bottom line
The factual record in major reporting is clear: Trump’s January 20, 2025 clemency included pardons and commutations that directly affected Proud Boys members and leaders — including the full pardon of Enrique Tarrio and commutations for others — producing immediate releases and sparking intense debate over accountability, national security, and the limits of presidential clemency [1] [6] [2]. Where reporting cannot establish private motives beyond public statements, sources differ sharply on whether the action is redemptive or a dangerous signal, and that division defines the continuing political and legal argument [4] [10].