My friend is assuring me that Trump has made life much easier and affordable than life under Biden. Things like food and rent. Is he really right?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Was this fact-check helpful?
1. Summary of the results
The analyses reveal a complex and contradictory picture regarding whether Trump has made life more affordable than Biden. The evidence suggests your friend's claim is not supported by current data.
Current Economic Reality:
- Consumer prices have risen only 2.4% annually under Trump's recent policies, which is less than initially predicted [1]
- However, the Biden-Harris Administration period saw prices increase by 20 percent with paychecks not covering as much as they previously did [2]
- Biden's tenure included strong job market gains and GDP growth but was marred by high inflation and increased costs for housing, healthcare, and childcare [3]
Future Concerns:
- Trump's tariff policies are projected to cause significant price increases for everyday items, with estimates suggesting an average increase of $5,000 per year for middle-class families [4]
- As inventories of pre-tariff goods are depleted, prices may rise substantially in the coming months [1]
Public Perception vs. Reality:
- 46% of Americans attribute the current economic state to Trump rather than Biden [5]
- The economic comparison shows mixed results for both presidents, with each having distinct successes and challenges [6]
2. Missing context/alternative viewpoints
Housing Market Complexities:
The analyses reveal that Trump's "One Big Beautiful Bill" Act contains provisions that could both help and harm housing affordability - while extending the Low-Income Housing Tax Credit, it also blocks local governments from regulating rent-setting algorithms, potentially favoring wealthy buyers and landlords [7].
Economic Growth Paradox:
A crucial missing perspective is that Biden's strong economic performance may have actually contributed to Trump's electoral success, as voters historically favor Republicans during periods of economic growth [8]. This suggests the relationship between economic performance and political perception is more nuanced than simple cause-and-effect.
Beneficiaries of Different Narratives:
- Republican politicians and Trump supporters benefit from promoting the narrative that Trump's policies are more affordable
- Wealthy landlords and buyers would benefit from Trump's housing deregulation policies [7]
- Senator Brian Schatz and Democratic politicians benefit from emphasizing the negative impacts of Trump's tariff policies [4]
3. Potential misinformation/bias in the original statement
Timing and Attribution Issues:
Your friend's statement contains a fundamental timing error - it attributes current affordability improvements to Trump when the analyses show that inflation and high costs were primarily issues during the Biden administration [2] [9]. The claim conflates future policy promises with current economic reality.
Selective Evidence:
The statement ignores substantial evidence that Trump's proposed tariff policies will likely increase costs significantly for food, housing, and other essentials [4]. It also overlooks the mixed economic record that shows both presidents had successes and failures in different areas [6].
Oversimplification:
The friend's assurance presents a black-and-white comparison when the analyses reveal a complex economic landscape where wages struggled to keep pace with inflation under Biden [9], but Trump's future policies may worsen affordability through tariffs [1] [4]. The reality is that neither administration has definitively "solved" affordability issues.