Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
How has the undocumented immigrant population in the US changed since 2010?
Executive Summary
Since 2010 the consensus across major analyses is that the undocumented immigrant population in the United States stabilized after a mid‑2000s peak, fell through the Great Recession, and then shifted upward again in the early 2020s, but the magnitude of the rise and current level are contested: Pew reported 14 million in 2023, while other groups report figures clustered around 11–12 million [1] [2] [3]. Disagreement stems from different estimation methods, data sources and assumptions about visa overstays, leading to a range of credible estimates and persistent uncertainty [4] [5].
1. What people are claiming — a compact inventory of the competing messages that matter
Multiple claims appear repeatedly in the record: one set of authorities argues the undocumented population peaked near 12 million in 2007, declined during and after the Great Recession, then remained roughly flat through the 2010s before resuming growth after 2020 [4] [6]. A second set of analyses shows modest net declines since 2010 with estimates near 11.0 million in 2022 and small percentage changes versus 2010 [2] [7]. A third, more recent claim from Pew contends the undocumented population rose to a record 14 million in 2023, driven by migration from Central and South America and increases in visa overstays, a claim that revises upward prior consensus [1] [5]. Each claim rests on different data streams and methodological choices, so the central factual contest is magnitude, not direction.
2. Recent numbers that change the narrative — which data moved the debate and when
Three data releases set the current contours: provisional Center for Migration Studies (CMS) estimates placed the population at 11.7 million in July 2023, noting an almost 800,000 year‑over‑year rise and shifts in country of origin away from Mexico [3]. Statista and related compilations show slightly lower series with roughly 11.0–11.6 million through 2022, framing a comparatively modest change since 2010 [7] [2]. Pew’s 2025 analysis pushed the upper boundary with a headline 14 million estimate for 2023, explicitly stating their residual‑method approach and comparing it to DHS and other conventional methods [1] [5]. The timing of releases matters: Pew’s later estimate incorporates newer administrative and survey signals that earlier studies could not.
3. Why different methods give different answers — the methodological fault lines
Researchers use two broad approaches: residual estimation (comparing census/survey totals to counts of lawful residents) and administrative tallies plus modeled visa overstays and enforcement flows. Residual methods historically produced estimates clustered around 10.5–11.5 million, emphasizing long‑standing population stability since about 2009 [6]. Administrative and mixed‑model approaches that more aggressively account for recently observed border encounters, asylum processing, and visa overstays produce higher estimates—including Pew’s 14 million—because they treat recent surge dynamics and undercount adjustments differently [4] [1]. Assumptions about undercount rates, return migration, and overstays are decisive; small changes in those assumptions shift population totals by millions, which explains the divergent headline numbers.
4. The trend story since 2010 — what actually changed in composition and size
Across sources, the core trend is coherent: decline from a mid‑2000s peak into the early 2010s, relative stability through much of the 2010s, and growth beginning around 2021 [4] [5]. The growth after 2020 is attributed mainly to increased entries and overstays from non‑Mexican origin countries—particularly Central and South America and parts of Asia—while the Mexican‑born undocumented population has declined [3] [8]. Some series show only modest net change since 2010 (a small percentage decline or flat trajectory), emphasizing that the difference since 2010 is more about composition and entry routes than an unambiguous, steadily rising headcount [2] [6].
5. Regional, demographic and policy dynamics that matter — the changing face of unauthorized immigration
Analysts converge on two consequential shifts: first, the decline in the Mexico‑born share and rise in migrants from Central and South America and Asia; second, the aging and longer‑tenure profile of many undocumented residents, with a substantial share having lived in the U.S. for a decade or more [2] [8]. These changes alter the policy and social implications—longer‑tenure populations are more integrated economically and socially—so even when totals are disputed, composition matters for policy responses [2] [8].
6. Bottom line, reliability and remaining uncertainties — how to read these numbers
The bottom line is that the undocumented population did not follow a simple monotonic path since 2010: it fell from a mid‑2000s high, was relatively stable in the 2010s, and evidence points to renewed growth in the early 2020s, with credible estimates ranging roughly from about 11 million to 14 million for 2022–2023 depending on method [4] [3] [1]. The most important remaining uncertainty is measurement, driven by undercounts, assumptions about overstays and return migration, and changing enforcement/processing realities; these factors make single‑number headlines misleading without methodological context [4] [5]. Policymakers and journalists should quote ranges, specify methods, and highlight compositional shifts rather than rely on any single point estimate [6] [5].