Which US presidents have required a federal employee loyalty pledge?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Was this fact-check helpful?
1. Summary of the results
The analyses provided indicate that President Harry S. Truman required a federal employee loyalty pledge, as he ordered loyalty checks of federal employees in 1947, establishing a sweeping loyalty investigation of federal employees [1]. This is further supported by the fact that Truman signed Executive Order 9835, also known as the 'Loyalty Order', which established the first general loyalty program in the United States [2]. Additionally, there are concerns that President Donald Trump has also demanded loyalty from federal employees, with some sources suggesting that he has required federal job applicants to write essays on how they would help implement his agenda, which was seen as a loyalty oath [3]. Furthermore, Trump has been accused of violating the Hatch Act by demanding partisan loyalty from civil servants and requiring them to be loyal to him, rather than the United States [4]. It is also worth noting that former FBI Director James Comey was asked by President Donald Trump for a personal assurance or pledge of loyalty, which Comey refused to provide [5].
2. Missing context/alternative viewpoints
One key piece of missing context is the historical context of the loyalty pledge during the Cold War era, and how it compares to the current demands for loyalty by President Trump [4]. Another alternative viewpoint is the importance of federal employees being accountable to more than just the president's executive orders, highlighting the need for a balance of powers and professional standards in the federal government [6]. Additionally, the analyses do not provide a comprehensive list of all US presidents who have required a federal employee loyalty pledge, only mentioning Truman and Trump [1] [3] [5]. The Trump administration's proposed rule that would allow the examination of the suitability and fitness of federal employees at any time, not just during the hiring process, has also raised concerns about the potential for political loyalty tests and the erosion of due process protections for federal employees [7]. Federal workers from over 50 agencies have signed a letter condemning the Trump administration for executive overreach and urging Congress to step in, which highlights the concerns of federal employees about the demands for loyalty [8].
3. Potential misinformation/bias in the original statement
The original statement may be misleading as it only asks about US presidents who have required a federal employee loyalty pledge, without providing context about the historical era or the specific circumstances of each president's demands for loyalty [1] [3] [5]. The sources suggest that the demand for loyalty by President Trump is a violation of the Hatch Act and an erosion of due process protections for federal employees, which may indicate a bias in the original statement towards downplaying the concerns about Trump's actions [7] [4]. The fact that some sources discuss the importance of federal employees being accountable to more than just the president's executive orders, and the need for a balance of powers and professional standards in the federal government, may indicate that the original statement is biased towards supporting the demands for loyalty by presidents [6]. The sources that benefit from this framing are those that support the idea of a strong executive branch and the president's authority to demand loyalty from federal employees, while the sources that are critical of this idea, such as federal workers and those who emphasize the importance of a balance of powers, may be marginalized [8] [4].