Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
What is the USDA count of noncitizen SNAP recipients in 2023 and 2024?
Executive Summary
USDA data and contemporaneous fact-checks converge on a clear figure for fiscal year 2023: roughly 1.7–1.8 million non‑citizens received SNAP benefits, representing about 4–5% of recipients. For 2024 the USDA published overall SNAP participation numbers but did not publish a comparable, explicit non‑citizen count in the examined sources, leaving the 2024 non‑citizen tally unreported in those documents [1] [2] [3].
1. What people actually claimed and where the disagreement starts
Multiple public claims and media reports contrasted the share of non‑citizens in SNAP with the program’s total caseload; the central, testable claim is numerical: "How many non‑citizens received SNAP in 2023 and 2024?" One thread of analysis asserts that USDA data shows non‑citizens were under 5% of SNAP beneficiaries in 2023 but offers no raw count [3]. Independent analyses synthesize USDA household characteristics and produce a concrete FY2023 estimate of approximately 1.7–1.8 million non‑citizen recipients, calculated from a ~4.4% share applied to the program’s roughly 40 million beneficiaries that year [1]. The disagreement is not about 2023 so much as about 2024’s lack of a public, USDA breakdown in the cited materials [4] [5].
2. The clearest USDA-backed figure for 2023 and how analysts derived it
USDA’s FY2023 household characteristics and associated fact-checks consistently report that non‑citizens composed a small share of SNAP recipients, broken into refugees (~1.1%) and other non‑citizens (~3.3%). Analysts translate these percentages into a head‑count by applying them to the program’s total recipient pool, yielding an estimate of roughly 1.7–1.8 million non‑citizens on SNAP in fiscal 2023 [1] [6]. This method is the transparent route used by multiple outlets and fact‑checks: starting from USDA percentage breakdowns and the program’s total enrollment yields a consistent numeric estimate that matches reporting across several investigations [2] [6].
3. Why 2024 numbers remain unsettled and what the sources say
For fiscal year 2024 the sources reviewed provide robust overall SNAP metrics—average monthly participation (about 41.7 million) and aggregate spending—but they do not publish a direct USDA head‑count of non‑citizen recipients analogous to 2023’s breakdown. News coverage and public analyses note the absence of a discrete USDA 2024 non‑citizen figure, and therefore reporters and analysts stop short of producing an official FY2024 non‑citizen tally [2] [4]. The practical consequence is that the best available 2024 information is program‑wide totals without a USDA‑issued non‑citizen subset in the cited documents [2].
4. How independent analysts and fact‑checkers compare and reconcile the data
Independent analysts and fact‑checking outlets use USDA percentage tables, the Migration Policy Institute’s household analyses, and program enrollment totals to cross‑check claims. The Migration Policy Institute offers household‑level estimates based on older survey data [7] and does not provide USDA‑reported counts for 2023 or 2024, so its work is supportive context rather than a direct source for USDA counts [5]. Fact‑checks and policy outlets point to consistency: USDA‑derived percentages and program totals converge around the 1.7–1.8 million estimate for 2023, while the absence of a 2024 breakdown leaves analysts reliant on caveats and extrapolation rather than an official USDA count [6] [1].
5. What important context and caveats are omitted from headlines
Headlines often omit that eligibility rules and household composition matter: some non‑citizens are categorically ineligible for SNAP while others (refugees, certain lawful non‑citizens) are eligible; mixed‑status households complicate counting because survey reports and administrative counts can diverge [5] [8]. The Migration Policy Institute’s 2019‑based estimates show substantial numbers of immigrant households interacting with SNAP in different eligibility categories, a nuance that administrative percentage breakdowns do not fully capture [5]. Additionally, reporting sometimes conflates foreign‑born, naturalized, and non‑citizen categories; USDA tabulations separate these groups, which affects headline interpretations [6].
6. Bottom line for decision‑makers and the public
The most defensible, evidence‑based statement from the reviewed material is that FY2023 saw about 1.7–1.8 million non‑citizen SNAP recipients (roughly 4–5% of beneficiaries), derived from USDA percentage breakdowns and program totals. For FY2024 no explicit USDA non‑citizen count appears in the examined sources, so any numeric claim about 2024’s non‑citizen caseload requires explicit disclosure of methodology or an acknowledgement that it is an estimate rather than a published USDA figure [1] [2] [3]. Policymakers and journalists should cite the USDA percentages and note the 2024 data gap rather than presenting an unsupported head‑count.