Which prominent Democrats compared Trump to Hitler in 2016 and 2020 and what exact words did they use?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
Multiple public figures, journalists and organizations compared Donald Trump to Adolf Hitler across 2016 and 2020 — but most of the examples in contemporary reporting are not single-line, on-the-record quotes by “prominent Democrats” naming “Trump is Hitler.” Instead, reporting shows a mix of: private messages (e.g., JD Vance’s 2016 Facebook remark that Trump was “America’s Hitler” surfaced later) and campaign/advocacy materials and opinion pieces that explicitly draw parallels (e.g., the Jewish Democratic Council ad in 2020). Reuters documents Vance’s 2016 private line verbatim: “I go back and forth … or that he's America’s Hitler” [1]. The Jewish Democratic Council ad in 2020 used imagery linking Trump and Nazi Germany [2] [3].
1. Who actually used the H‑word — public quotes versus private notes
Reporting distinguishes private commentary from public Democratic leaders’ statements. Reuters relied on a recovered 2016 private Facebook message in which JD Vance wrote: “I go back and forth between thinking Trump is a cynical asshole like Nixon who wouldn't be that bad (and might even prove useful) or that he's America's Hitler” — that line was reported about a private 2016 message, not a public Democratic official’s attack in 2016 [1]. Major outlets and scholars later catalogued many comparisons by commentators and campaign ads rather than an authoritative list of prominent Democrats publicly declaring “Trump = Hitler” in a single soundbite [4] [2].
2. 2020: organized ads and advocacy invoked Nazi parallels, not always named politicians
In 2020 the Jewish Democratic Council of America produced a digital ad that juxtaposed footage of Hitler and Nazi rallies with Trump clips and implied parallels; press coverage described the ad’s use of Hitler imagery and headlines asserting Trump praises dictators [2]. Jewish groups criticized Holocaust analogies even as some Jewish Democrats defended the ad; reporting notes the ad’s voiceover said “Donald Trump praises dictators” and used footage of Hitler to make the parallel [2] [3]. That was an organized Democratic-aligned group’s messaging, not necessarily an on-the-record line from Joe Biden or other top party officeholders quoted as saying “Trump is Hitler” [2] [3].
3. Opinion writers, historians and some Democrats drew parallels — but often with qualifiers
Academic and opinion pieces drew structured comparisons between Trump’s tactics and early Nazi moves; scholars urged care while some authors listed specific similarities (e.g., rhetorical style, “big lie,” attacks on institutions). Cambridge scholarship and historians cautioned that overbroad analogies can be counterproductive while also documenting why some parallels attracted attention after 2016 [4] [5]. Opinion pieces and civil‑rights writers have laid out lists of ways Trump resembled early Hitler-era strategies; those pieces framed the comparison as analytical rather than a literal equating [6] [7].
4. Disputes over strategy: Democrats warned it can “backfire” even when comparisons appear
Several sources record that pundits and strategists — including commentators sympathetic to Democratic aims — warned that invoking Hitler could alienate voters or lessen credibility, with names like Frank Bruni and political scientists arguing hyperbolic comparisons risked “crying wolf” in 2016 [4]. The Hill reported Democratic operatives debating whether Hitler analogies were useful messaging in later cycles [8]. These articles show intra‑party disagreement about rhetorical usefulness even where critics acknowledged alarming behaviors [8] [4].
5. What sources do and do not say about “prominent Democrats” using exact phrasings
Available sources document ads, opinion pieces and commentators drawing explicit parallels and provide at least one private 2016 quote that used the phrase “America’s Hitler” [1] [2]. The materials provided do not produce a neat roster of named, prominent Democratic officeholders in 2016 or 2020 who, in on‑the‑record public remarks, said the exact phrase “Donald Trump is Hitler” or identical formulations; when reporting shows public comparisons they are often in advocacy ads, opinion essays, or analytical pieces rather than a single line from a named Democratic leader [2] [3] [4]. If you are looking for verbatim public quotes from specific Democratic officeholders in 2016 and 2020, available sources do not mention a compiled list of such on‑the‑record lines.
6. Why the form of the comparison matters — private note, ad, or analysis changes meaning
Journalistic coverage separates a private Facebook remark (Vance’s 2016 private comparison resurfaced later) from coordinated political advertising that uses Holocaust imagery to press a case (JDCA’s 2020 ad) and from scholarly or opinion parallels that enumerate historical analogies [1] [2] [4]. Each carries different intent and audience: a private quip, a partisan ad designed to shock, and an analytic article drawing structural comparisons. Reporting flags that weaponizing Holocaust analogies carries political and ethical costs and has prompted pushback from Jewish organizations and historians [3] [4].
Limitations and next steps: this compilation uses the provided reporting and does not purport to be exhaustive of every media or social‑media instance in 2016 and 2020. If you want, I can search for named, on‑the‑record quotes by specific Democratic officeholders in those years and return verbatim citations — but that requires additional sources beyond those supplied here.