Did Zohran Mamdani apologize or clarify his 9/11 remark and when did that occur?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
Zohran Mamdani did not issue a widely reported public apology specifically for his 9/11 anecdote about an aunt; instead, in late October 2025 he offered a clarification that he was not referring to a “biological aunt,” an action framed by some outlets as damage control after conservative backlash, while he separately apologized publicly in mid‑October 2025 for earlier 2020 remarks about the NYPD (Oct. 16, 2025) [1] [2] [3].
1. The remark and the backlash
In a late‑October campaign speech Mamdani described an uncle advising family members — including an aunt who stopped taking the subway after Sept. 11 — as a way to highlight the long reach of post‑9/11 Islamophobia, a line that quickly drew sharp conservative criticism and mocking posts on social platforms, including reaction from national figures such as Vice President J.D. Vance [1].
2. The clarification: timing and text
Facing that criticism, outlets reported that Mamdani “was prompted to do some damage control” and publicly clarified at the end of October 2025 that his reference was not to a biological aunt but was meant more broadly to illustrate the fear Muslim women experienced after 9/11; that clarification is documented in reporting dated Oct. 27–28, 2025 [2] [1].
3. Apology versus clarification — what the record shows
The available reporting distinguishes the late‑October clarification about the 9/11 anecdote from a separate, explicit apology Mamdani gave earlier in October 2025 about his 2020 comments describing the NYPD as “racist” and calling for defunding; he publicly apologized to rank‑and‑file officers during a Fox News appearance on Oct. 16, 2025, and said he had also apologized privately to some officers [3] [4].
4. How different audiences framed the response
Conservative commentators and some outlets portrayed Mamdani’s original anecdote as minimization of 9/11 victims and pushed for an apology, while pro‑Mamdani and more sympathetic coverage framed his remarks as a personal account intended to expose Islamophobia and treated his clarification as context, not capitulation; this partisan split shaped coverage and amplified demands for either apology or retraction after the speech [1] [2].
5. Limits of the available reporting
The cited stories document the speech, the social‑media backlash, the late‑October clarification that he wasn’t referencing a biological aunt, and the separate Oct. 16, 2025 NYPD apology, but the sources here do not include a verbatim full transcript of Mamdani’s clarification or an unequivocal, standalone public apology specifically labeled as for the 9/11 anecdote, so assertions about an explicit apology for that particular line cannot be made from the provided material [1] [2] [3].
6. Bottom line
In sum, late October 2025 coverage shows Mamdani clarified the 9/11 anecdote — saying he was not referring to a biological aunt — rather than formally apologizing for having raised the anecdote as reported; a distinct public apology was issued earlier in October 2025 for his 2020 NYPD‑related comments, and partisan responders interpreted the clarification and apology through opposing political lenses [2] [1] [3].