Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
How many roll call votes did Mamdani miss from 2020-2025
Executive Summary
Zohran Mamdani’s exact number of missed roll-call votes from 2020–2025 cannot be confirmed from the materials provided: reporting cites a claim that he missed roughly 50% of Assembly roll-call votes and a separate figure that he missed 231 roll-call votes in the last year, but the dataset supplied lacks comprehensive official Assembly vote records to reconcile those numbers. The sources raise competing portraits—one frames absences as widespread and tied to his mayoral campaign, while another documents a one-year tally—so a definitive, multi-year total for 2020–2025 is not established by the available analyses [1] [2].
1. What the claims actually say—and where they diverge
Two distinct claims appear in the provided analyses and they do not line up as a single account. One claim reports that Mamdani missed approximately 50 percent of New York State Assembly roll-call votes; that framing appears in a June 2025 fact-check-style report and links the absences to his activities during the mayoral campaign, but notes the dataset used is incomplete and lacks official legislative roll-call logs [1]. A second claim gives a precise count—231 missed roll-call votes “over the last year”—but that figure is explicitly limited in time and therefore cannot be extrapolated to cover the full 2020–2025 period without additional records [2]. The two claims are not directly commensurate: one is a proportional summary across an unspecified span, the other is a discrete one-year count.
2. Gaps in the evidence: what is missing to answer the question definitively
The supplied analyses repeatedly underline a critical evidentiary gap: there are no comprehensive official Assembly roll-call records in these items covering the full 2020–2025 window, and one report explicitly states it only documents the last year [2]. Without access to the Assembly’s roll-call databases or an authoritative compilation from the legislative clerk, neither the percent-missed claim nor the 231-vote figure can be validated or aggregated across multiple years. The June 2025 reportage that mentions a roughly 50% absentee rate flags that the dataset it used lacked official confirmation, which means researchers must obtain official vote logs or complete third-party datasets before producing a reliable 2020–2025 total [1].
3. How different framings change public perception and the potential agendas behind them
Framing matters: stating “50% of votes missed” paints a broad pattern of absenteeism and can shape narratives about dedication to the Assembly, especially during a mayoral campaign, whereas saying “231 votes missed last year” offers a concrete-sounding number that still lacks broader context. The June 2025 item that couples the high miss-rate figure with Mamdani’s mayoral campaign activity suggests a political explanation for absences [1]. Conversely, articles about his electoral success and campaign [3] [4] [5] do not delve into voting attendance, indicating selective emphasis across outlets. These divergences suggest competing agendas: fact-checking or accountability-focused pieces foreground absenteeism, while campaign and election coverage highlight electoral outcomes without the same scrutiny [1] [3] [4].
4. What can be reliably stated now and what requires further verification
From the analyses provided, the only reliable, bounded statements are: a report asserts Mamdani missed 231 roll-call votes in the last year (explicitly limited in timeframe) and a June 2025 item characterizes his absentee rate as about 50 percent but flags dataset limitations and lack of official Assembly records [2] [1]. Anything beyond those immediate claims—such as a cumulative count spanning 2020–2025 or a verified percentage across that five-year span—requires retrieval of the Assembly’s official roll-call records or a verified dataset that spans the entire period. Without that verification, any multi-year total would be speculative and methodologically unsound [1] [2].
5. Next steps for someone seeking a definitive answer
To move from contested claims to a definitive 2020–2025 figure, one must obtain official roll-call records from the New York State Assembly clerk or a complete, date-stamped dataset from a reputable tracker that covers every session vote across those years, then reconcile those logs with attendance/recorded votes for Mamdani. A rigorous approach would calculate annual and cumulative missed roll-call tallies, show the share of total roll-call votes missed each year, and document any excused absences or official leaves that affect interpretation. The current sources make partial claims but explicitly lack the comprehensive official data needed to produce a verified, 2020–2025 total [1] [2].